"Despite the obvious historical and ideological unity of cricket and imperial Christianity, we are faced here again with competing versions of the truth. If such a connection really exists, why did it take Knott's conversion to illustrate for him the error of his ways? Why were the imprecations of those who condemned the events in question as violations of the moral code of cricket ineffective? Does this indicate that there is a conflict or that while there may be a practical conjunction one can heed the code only when its source is not human law but God's Law? Can only Christians be true cricketers? Can true cricketers be non-Christians? In the Indian context, can only Hindus be 'Indian' cricketers? What are we to make of the 'Islamic' nature of Pakistan and Pakistani cricket and Yusef Youhana, a Christian Test player? The debates over natural law versus human positivism are as central to the understanding of Noonan's jurisprudence as they are to the understanding of cricket. There are, of course, counter-Christian narratives or different Christian narratives in cricket which contradict and enrich the story just as there both secular and competing Hindu or Islamic renderings of the complex texts and practices of Indiana and Pakistani cricket. A triumph over one narrow view of Christianity served to 'democratize' the game permitting the playing of the game on Sundays in England by melding capitalism and anti-Puritanism in an interesting and textually complex Weberian interpretive ploy."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
David Fraser, “Cricket and the Law: The Man in White is Always Right”, (2005), p. 333
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Cricket
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Cricket
41 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Cricket →
Related Quotes
"Of all the races in the Galaxy, only the English could possibly revive the memory of the most horrific wars ever to s…"
"I think sledging is healthy for the game. I don't really call it sledging -- at the end of the day it is gamesmanship…"
"He is the below average cricketer, and there are many of him. But he is more important to the game than the most emin…"
"After years of patient study (and with cricket there can be no other kind), I have decided that there is nothing wron…"
"It is not true that the English invented cricket as a way of making all other human endeavours look interesting and l…"
"I am quite certain that if the rest of the world vanished overnight and the development of cricket was left in Austra…"
"[T]hroughout the late twentieth and early twenty first centuries, the English have gradually lost their political con…"
"Nandy’s challenge to the view of cricket being the quintessential English game goes some way to dispute the idea that…"
"The core elements of rule of law discourse which are so deeply embedded in cricket as a practice became basic normati…"
"In Affectionate Remembrance of ENGLISH CRICKET, which died at the Oval on 29th AUGUST, 1882, Deeply lamented by a lar…"