"The notion that clones are “identical twins born at different times” is scientifically wrong and very misleading. There is a fundamental distinction between identical twins produced naturally and a SCNT “clone.” Identical twins normally arise by the splitting of an already fertilized egg, so that the two twins share not only the same genetic complement but also have split the cytoplasm from the egg. With SCNT clones, a very different process takes place (Campbell et al. 1996). The egg [from which the nucleus has been removed] comes from one animal, the nuclear material comes from a somatic cell from another animal. This somatic cell is usually fused with the enucleated egg, and then is stimulated electrically or biochemically, while the resulting embryo, if it starts to grow, is then transplanted into the womb of a third animals which acts as the surrogate mother. Thus, a clone of an existing animal will not share the same egg cytoplasm as the original animal, and, while it might share the genes of the original animal, the fact that a nucleus from a somatic cell has been used means that the genes in the somatic cell are subtly different that genes from a fertilized egg. As the FDA notes, the genes in somatic cells need to be reprogrammed so that they are more like fertilized cells. Indeed, research has suggested that, for proper development to occur, a donor nucleus must undergo a reversal of differentiation and a genome-wide epigenetic reprogramming (Riek et al. 2001). Difficulties in this process are believed to be the cause of the high rate of birth defects, and other health problems, in clones. While the FDA acts like a lot is known about epigenetic reprogramming, the reality is that, some ten years after Dolly, there is still a lot that is not know about epigenetic reprogramming which helps explain why the vast majority (e.g. 95%) of cloned embryos do not survive to adulthood."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Cloning
74 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Cloning →
Related Quotes
"A prominent biologist Lee Silver, once said that biology would be forever defined as BD and AD: before Dolly and afte…"
"Wilmut has always been clear about his ethical beliefs and has publicly voiced his approval of 'therapeutic cloning',…"
"Hard lessons have been learnt by past situations involving science and secrecy. Nobel Peace Prize winner Joseph Rotbl…"
"First, a suitable surrogate mother animal is required. For the mammoth this would need to be a cow (as best biologica…"
"If there are intact cells in this tissue they have been 'stored' frozen. However, if we think back to what actually h…"
""Let's say that one in a thousand cells were nevertheless viable, practical issues come into play. Given that we have…"
"Considered contrary to the moral law, since (it is in) opposition to the dignity both of human procreation and of the…"
"The delivered kid was genetically identical to the bucardo. In species such as bucardo, cloning is the only possibili…"
"Dr. Josef Mengele: Do you know what I saw on the television in my motel room at one o'clock this morning? Films of Hi…"
"The first obstacle to cloning your dog is that $100,000 cost. The second is getting the right kind of cells. It's eas…"