"…[I]n three notable instances the Court has suffered severely from self-inflicted wounds. The first of these was the Dred Scott case. … There the Supreme Court decided that Dred Scott, a negro, not being a citizen could not sue in the United States Courts and that Congress could not prohibit slavery in the territories. … [T]he grave injury that the Court sustained through its decision has been universally recognized. Its action was a public calamity. … [W]idespread and bitter attacks upon the judges who joined in the decision undermined confidence in the Court. … It was many years before the Court, even under new judges, was able to retrieve its reputation.…[The second instance was] the legal tender cases decided in 1870. … From the standpoint of the effect on public opinion there can be no doubt that the reopening of the case was a serious mistake and the overruling in such a short time, and by one vote, of the previous decision shook popular respect for the Court.… [The third instance happened] [t]wenty-five years later, when the Court had recovered its prestige, [and] its action in the income tax cases gave occasion for a bitter assault. … [After questions about the validity of the income tax] had been reserved owing to an equal division of the Court, a reargument was ordered and in the second decision the act was held to be unconstitutional by a majority of one. Justice Jackson was ill at the time of the first argument but took part in the final decision, voting in favor of the validity of the statute. It was evident that the result [holding the statute invalid] was brought about by a change in the vote of one of the judges who had participated in the first decision. … [T]he decision of such an important question by a majority of one after one judge had changed his vote aroused a criticism of the Court which has never been entirely stilled.""
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Justices of the Supreme Court of the United StatesLawyers from New York (state)United States Secretaries of StateUnited States presidential candidates, 1908United States presidential candidates, 1916
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
"The Supreme Court of the United States: Its Foundation, Methods and Achievements," Columbia University Press, p. 50 (1928). .
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Charles_Evans_Hughes
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Charles Evans Hughes
Charles Evans Hughes (11 April 1862 – 27 August 1948) was a Republican politician and jurist who served as Governor of New York, United States Secretary of State, Associate Justice and Chief Justice of the United States.
30 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Charles Evans Hughes →
Related Quotes
"We are under a Constitution, but the Constitution is what the judges say it is, and the judiciary is the safeguard of…"
"While democracy must have its organizations and controls, its vital breath is individual liberty."
"No greater mistake can be made than to think that our institutions are fixed or may not be changed for the worse. … I…"
"A man has to live with himself, and he should see to it that he always has good company."
"When we lose the right to be different, we lose the privilege to be free."
"The most ominous spirit of our times, as it seems to me, is the indication of the growth of an intolerent spirit. It …"
"The power of administrative bodies to make finding of fact which may be treated as conclusive, if there is evidence b…"
"We still proclaim the old ideals of liberty but we cannot voice them without anxiety in our hearts. The question is n…"
"I think that it is a fallacy to suppose that helpful cooperation in the future will be assured by the attempted compu…"
"[Dissents are] appeals to the brooding spirit of the law, to the intelligence of another day."