"So that in the end, the greatest of all the bourgeois philosophers, the most encyclopedic mind that Europe had produced, the founder of the dialectic, in Engels’ words, the maker of an epoch, could not transcend his historic barrier and was recaptured in the rationalist trap from which he had sought so profoundly to extricate European thought. Hegel destroyed all dogmatisms but one – the dogmatism of the backwardness of the masses. Once the revolutionary solution of the contradiction escaped him, he clung to the bureaucracy. The intellectual elite would rescue society and discipline the revolting masses. Reinstated were uncritical materialism, a purely material existence for the masses, and uncritical idealism, the solution of social crisis by the intellectual bureaucracy. We today who have seen Stalinism and the labor bureaucracy the world over can first fully comprehend this, Marx’s essential critique of Hegel. Only the revolutionary proletariat, said Marx, can appropriate the dialectical logic of Hegel. Hegel himself, because he held fast to the intellectual elite, ended up, despite his thoroughgoing analysis of contradiction and negativity, in the crass materialism and crass idealism of the state bureaucracy."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Journalists from Trinidad and TobagoHistorians from Trinidad and TobagoEssayists from Trinidad and TobagoPlaywrights from Trinidad and TobagoTrotskyists
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/C._L._R._James
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
C. L. R. James
Cyril Lionel Robert James (4 January 1901 – 19 May 1989) was a Trinidadian-born anti-colonial Marxist activist and writer.
49 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by C. L. R. James →
Related Quotes
"The crisis of production today is the crisis of the antagonism between manual and intellectual labor. The problem of …"
"Rationalism is the philosophy of bourgeois political economy. It is materialist and not idealist in so far as it comb…"
"Today, from end to end of the world, men know that democracy is bankrupt. What is to take its place they do not know.…"
"The philosophy of Stalinism is the philosophy of the elite, the bureaucracy, the organizers, the leaders, clothed in …"
"For the Stalinist bureaucracy, state-property converts labor "from the drab burden it was under capitalism into a mat…"
"On the surface it appeared that the Stalinist intervention was to defend the materialism of Marx against the idealism…"
"The steps of Hegel’s decline are here undeviatingly retraced. Hegel, who did not know the socialized proletariat, beg…"
"To believe that this vigorous offensive in every sphere is a question of nationalism is a mistake as crippling as the…"
"Since the end of World War II, and particularly with the philosophic systematization of the new idealism in 1947, the…"
"All previous distinctions, politics and economics, war and peace, agitation and propaganda, party and mass, the indiv…"