"It is probably best to start off by noting that Hayek knew a lot about Mill, probably for a time more than any other contemporary scholar. So we should not underestimate him. Next, what he had to say about Mill, what portion of Mill’s work he drew upon, was very much dictated by the sort of project he was working on. When he was making an argument about how the British liberal tradition lost its bearings, or about how Comtean positivism came to be known and gained influence across Europe, Mill was classed among the perpetrators. When he was writing about what made the British liberal tradition great, Mill could be one of the heroes. There is, I think, no inconsistency in the fact that Hayek could hold both views simultaneously."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Educators from the United StatesHistorians from the United StatesEconomists from the United StatesAustrian School economistsDuke University faculty
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
"Hayek and Mill", History of Political Economy (2008)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Bruce_Caldwell_(economist)
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Bruce Caldwell (economist)
8 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Bruce Caldwell (economist) →
Related Quotes
"Critics argue that Hayek mixed a number of ethical and political philosophies in constructing his system, positions t…"
"There are two elements of Hayek’s background that justify our considering him an Austrian economist: first, that he w…"
"Some may wish to argue that Hayek was simply born with a sort of natural pessimism or cynicism, and that this generat…"
"It seems evident from his unpublished piece that his reading of the Mill-Taylor letters gave Hayek a bit of a shock. …"
"In his discussions of spontaneous orders, sometimes Hayek was simply trying to make the point that they exist; that i…"
"Hayek is a puzzle. Certainly he started out as one for me, now some twenty-odd years ago."
"He linked the notion of a spontaneous order that forms when agents follow (often simple) rules with the idea of compl…"
"Americans have always been especially prone to regard all things as resulting from the free choice of a free will. Pr…"
"Democracy is clearly most appropriate for countries which enjoy an economic surplus and least appropriate for countri…"
"Here, for the last time together, appeared a triumvirate of old men, relics of a golden age, who still towered like g…"