"Edmund Gettier convinced most philosophers that the received wisdom of millennia about the concept of knowledge was mistaken: “knowledge” was not simply a matter of having a justified, true belief … A justified true belief isn’t “knowledge” when the justification for the true belief isn’t the cause of why the agent holds the belief. As Philip Kitcher put the point, in explaining the stimulus Gettier provided to the “naturalistic” turn in epistemology: “the epistemic status of a belief state depends on the etiology of the state.” … We can understand, now, the logic of the hermeneutics of suspicion as exploiting precisely this point about the epistemic status of belief: we should be suspicious of the epistemic status of beliefs that have the wrong causal etiology. That’s the lesson of the Gettier counter-examples, and it is the lesson which underwrites the suspicion that Marx, Nietzsche, and Freud recommend by way of providing alternative causal trajectories to explain our beliefs. To be sure, beliefs with the wrong causal etiology might be true; but since they are no longer cases of knowledge, we have no reason to presume that to be the case."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesPhilosophers from the United StatesEducators from the United StatesJews from the United States
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Brian_Leiter
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Brian Leiter
13 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Brian Leiter →
Related Quotes
"If we can recover the naturalistic ambitions of Marx, Nietzsche, and Freud, … philosophy becomes relevant because the…"
"Perhaps more striking is the accuracy of many of Marx’s best-known qualitative predictions about the tendencies of ca…"
"The Marxian theory of ideology predicts that the ruling ideas in any well functioning society will be ideas that prom…"
"Rosen suggests that the rule of the few might simply be the result of coordination problems confronting the many in o…"
"Rosen would still demand, no doubt, an explanation of why the ruling class is so good at identifying and promoting it…"
"Nehamas invokes Nietzsche’s talk of the “eternal basic text of homo natura” (BGE 230, quoted above) as evidence of ae…"
"Just as Darwinian adaptationists assume that every biological phenomenon must be explained in terms of natural select…"
"Millions of people profess knowledge of the reality of God, claiming miracles witnessed or voices heard. If what real…"
"Beliefs arrived at the wrong way are suspect: that is the epistemological point exploited by the practitioners of the…"
"Continental morality critics are plainly not without ethical views of their own—namely, views, broadly, about the goo…"