"The other mistake that is widely attributed to Einstein is that he was on the wrong side in his famous debate with Niels Bohr over quantum mechanics, starting at the Solvay Congress of 1927 and continuing into the 1930s. In brief, Bohr had presided over the formulation of a “Copenhagen interpretation” of quantum mechanics, in which it is only possible to calculate the probabilities of the various possible outcomes of experiments. Einstein rejected the notion that the laws of physics could deal with probabilities, famously decreeing that God does not play dice with the cosmos. But history gave its verdict against Einstein—quantum mechanics went on from success to success, leaving Einstein on the sidelines. All this familiar story is true, but it leaves out an irony. Bohr’s version of quantum mechanics was deeply flawed, but not for the reason Einstein thought. The Copenhagen interpretation describes what happens when an observer makes a measurement, but the observer and the act of measurement are themselves treated classically. This is surely wrong: Physicists and their apparatus must be governed by the same quantum mechanical rules that govern everything else in the universe."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Steven Weinberg, "Einstein’s mistakes", Physics Today (2005)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Bohr%E2%80%93Einstein_debates
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Bohr–Einstein debates
17 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Bohr–Einstein debates →
Related Quotes
"To recap, I had four numbers to add together. If the total came to under 2, then Einstein’s version of quantum realit…"
"The discomfort that I feel is associated with the fact that the observed perfect quantum correlations seem to demand …"
"Bohr was inconsistent, unclear, willfully obscure and right. Einstein was consistent, clear, down-to-earth and wrong."
"The EPR paper came out in 1935 and for at least two decades no one paid much attention to it. However, in 1964, the l…"
"His thought experiment with photon and film had not challenged Heisenberg's principle, but now Einstein did turn his …"
"The mid-twentieth century “Bohr-Einstein debate” about quantum theory is often misinterpreted as a personal clash bet…"
"Einstein was not prepared to let us do what, to him, amounted to pulling the ground from under his feet. Later in lif…"
"Their dispute went to the fundamental heart of the design of the cosmos. Was there an objective reality that existed …"
"Einstein's thinking is always on the ontological level traditional in physics; trying to describe the realities of Na…"
"The famous debate between Einstein and Bohr began at the Solvay Council in 1927. The debate was about the interpretat…"