"Drucilla Cornell addresses the question of bodily integrity, personhood, and the legal protection of both in a related way, arguing that, the right to abortion should not be understood as the right to choose an abortion but as the right to realize the legitimacy of the individual woman's projection of her own bodily integrity, consistent with her imagination of herself at the time that she chooses to terminate her pregnancy. Here, in other words, personhood and bodily integrity are not about physical wholeness but about psychological or existential wholeness-the relationship between an intact body and a sense of self. A woman's identity (political and otherwise) is based on the projection of her physical and psychological self, and a legal system must protect a woman citizen's ability (and “right”) to maintain this identity. As Taub notes, although “far more sophisticated” than many other approaches, Cornell's analysis is also based both implicitly and explicitly upon a Lacanian interpretation of the mirroring process. Taub further argues that if we do not accept Lacanian analysis, Cornell's argument becomes problematic. I would respond, however, that psychological projections of the self based on bodily integrity are not any more constructed (or “false”) than physical projections of the same, and that Cornell's approach is therefore useful regardless of whether or not we accept the details of Lacanian analysis. Indeed, both the more “basic” approach and the more “sophisticated” approach appear to get at the same issue-the linkage of personhood or the self to the ideal of wholeness, and the need for legal structures or rights rhetoric to protect this connection."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
pp.59-60; Taub 1999, 455; Cornell 1995, 82; Taub 1999, 456.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Bodily_integrity
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Bodily integrity
48 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Bodily integrity →
Related Quotes
"Article 40 1. All citizens shall, as human persons, be held equal before the law. This shall not be held to mean that…"
"4. 1° No citizen shall be deprived of his personal liberty save in accordance with law. 2° Upon complaint being made …"
"That the general guarantee of personal rights in section 3 (1) of Art. 40 extends to rights not specified in Art. 40.…"
"Every person with disabilities has a right to respect for his or her physical and mental integrity on an equal basis …"
"[A]ll the while Florence was making its way through the courts, law enforcement officials were playing fast and loose…"
"Now recall the structure of negative liberty as it has long been conceived in the liberal political tradition. In con…"
"It is tempting to try to explain (away) rights conflict by pointing to the fact that very few rights are absolute. Th…"
"Some readers might now be thinking that their skepticism about the existence of a right to privacy has been more than…"
"The above issues have not been satisfactorily resolved at the conceptual level and it is largely because of this that…"
"I will not be arguing that bodily integrity is an inappropriate lens through which to view rape legislation or that v…"