"For instance Trumpp, in the introduction to his translation of the Adi Granth,cast serious doubton the historicity of Bhai Bala, a cherished figure in Sikh tradition. For long, Sikhs had believed that Guru Nanak was on his extensive tours steadfastly accompanied by Bhai Bala. Now all of a sudden this revered figure was shown to be a creature of the imagination. Trumpp based his conclusions on the fact that the oldest of the then extant janam-sakhis, the so-called Colebrooke manuscript that he had discovered at the India Office Library in London, did not mention any Bhai Bala.“ His name appeared only much later in the Sikh hagiographic tradition. The manuscript on which Trumpp based his findings had been donated by H.T. Colebrooke to the Library of East India House in 1815 or 1816, and accordingly came to be known by his name. Sikh intellectuals of the period knew nothing about this valuable manuscript and its contents. All that they could do to save face was to vilify Trumpp. His missionary background and intemperate use of language made him an easy target."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Harjot Oberoi - The Construction of Religious Boundaries_ Culture, Identity, and Diversity in the Sikh Tradition (1994, University of Chicago Press)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Bhai_Bala
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Bhai Bala
1466 – 1544
Bhai Bala (Punjabi: à¨à¨¾à¨ˆ ਬਾਲਾ 1466–1544), born in Talwandi Rai Bhoi into a Sandhu Jat family (now called Nankana Sahib in Pakistan), was a childhood friend and lifelong companion of Bhai Mardana and Guru Nanak. According to the Bhai Bala Janam Sakhis, he traveled with Guru Nanak and Bhai Mardana on all of their great journeys around the world including China, Mecca, and around India. He supposedly died in Khadur Sahib, in his late 70s, in 1544.
1 quote on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Bhai Bala →
Related Quotes
"Despite my profound reservations and over the unanimous advice of almost all the MPs from Punjab, you chose to appoin…"
"My heartiest congratulations to the people of India on the historic foundation laying of #RamMandir in #Ayodhya, whic…"
"Among Hindus and Sikhs resentment at the agitation is growing and, particularly in the case of the latter in an omino…"
"“In spite of the division of the country all of us Muslims, Hindus and Sikhs--have to live together. Let us, therefor…"
"In Tainch and Harnali about two dozen Sikhs were killed and brutalities committed in the latter place. About 30 women…"
"There was disappointment in Nehru’s leadership, but it never took away from the deep regard in which he was held for …"
"This is why it has been so astonishingly easy for the Gandhi dynasty to turn India’s oldest political party into a fa…"
"It was the first time an Indian prime minister had been so open about his religion and a tremor of fear went up the ‘…"
"“the word Hindutva is being used as a term of abuse […] it is used mostly in pejorative terms […] the debate appears …"
"If there is a single reason why Narendra Modi became the first prime minister in more than thirty years to get a full…"