"B.B. Lal made his name as an archaeologist in the 1950s and 60s by exploring the Painted Grey Ware culture, which he then identified as the Aryan invader culture during its expansion from the Panjab border zone deeper into India; but along the way he realized that his data offered no support to the AIT which he had been using as a prism through which to interpret the data... Especially in his case, this latter fact is remarkable. It was he who, as a young archaeologist in the 1950s, made his name by finally digging up the long-awaited proof of an Aryan invasion. He had identified a pottery style, the Painted Grey Ware (1200-800), as typifying the Aryans penetrating deeper into India. That is what was taught to us in university, and even recently-published books upholding the Aryan Invasion Theory cite this finding as âproofâ. But Lal himself has grown away from it. At the time, he had simply applied the reigning invasionist framework, until he understood that this was but a hypothetical construct unsupported by hard findings. ... Thus, the anti-invasionist case put forward by the archaeologists like B.B. Lal and the late S.P. Gupta has often been dismissed without further ado âbecause they are, not coincidentally, the same ones who claim to have discovered pillar-bases underneath the Babri mosque in Ayodhya and thus supported the Hindu claim to the siteâ. Of course, this finding on Hindu-Muslim relations in medieval history wouldnât make any difference to their case on the Aryan question in ancient history, at least not to scientists. ... But in this case there is an even more pertinent fact: the finding of the pillar-bases, ridiculed by self-appointed âexpertsâ and their foreign dupes, has been confirmed. Both the Archaeological Survey of India and the Allahabad High Court have, after gathering solid evidence during thorough excavations as well as questioning many âexpertsâ (whose performance under oath was extremely embarrassing, undercutting whatever credibility they had been credited with, see Jain 2013:201-273), ruled that there had indeed been a Hindu temple until it was demolished and its foundation (âpillar-basesâ) reused to underpin a mosque. These archaeologists were lambasted worldwide for upholding a case that has ultimately been proven correct.... On the Aryan question too, they may well end up being proven correct. Conversely, the anti-Hindu academics worldwide who parroted the âexpertsâ and expressed seething (though borrowed) hatred for the temple party, have been shown to have been babes in the wood, led by the nose by political agitators using the aura of the academic positions they had cornered to promote a very artificial lie, launched in the late 1980s against what had been a consensus about a pre-existing temple among all concerned parties. (see Elst 2011) On the Aryan question too, they might end up finding that they had safely chosen the side of a dominant opinion fated to be proven wrong... In our midst is the nonagenarian dean of Indian archaeology, Prof. B.B. Lal. I first heard from him in the 1980s at university in Leuven, Belgium, where Prof. Pierre Eggermont taught us that Lal had at last identified the Aryans on their way deeper into India, viz. through the Painted Grey Ware. That is how Lal first made his name: by identifying the theoretically deduced Aryan invasion with something tangible. Indeed, that is how Pradhan (2014:67) cites him even now: âLal considered Painted Grey Ware to be intrusiveâ. Yet, Lal has later described that identification as false and written books denying an invasion, e.g. Lal 2002. Like most Indian archaeologists, he has had to face the fact that all attempts to find traces of the Aryan invaders had proved erroneous. You all have heard him say it right here: âVedic culture and the Harappan cities are but the two sides of the same coin.â"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from IndiaNon-fiction authors from IndiaHistorians from IndiaIndologistsArchaeologists from India
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Elst, Koenraad (2018). Still no trace of an Aryan invasion: A collection on Indo-European origins.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/B._B._Lal
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
B. B. Lal
Braj Basi Lal (2 May 1921 â 10 September 2022), better known as B. B. Lal, was a renowned Indian archaeologist. He was the Director General of the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) from 1968 to 1972, and has served as Director of the Indian Institute of Advanced Studies, Shimla. Lal also served on various UNESCO committees.
18 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by B. B. Lal â
Related Quotes
"I don't say so, but my spade tells me so."
"It is true that the Rigveda does not provide us details of the inner layout of these forts, but surely the text was nâŚ"
"The great civilization of the Indian subcontinent, has had its roots deep in antiquity, some seven to eight thousand âŚ"
"What is that âsomethingâ, some inherent strength? Doubtless it lies in the liberal character of the Indian civilizatiâŚ"
"Here it may perhaps be stated straightaway that so far no unimpeachable evidence has been adduced to prove or even toâŚ"
"Under a project called âArchaeology of the Ramayana Sitesâ excavations were carried out between 1975 and 1986 at fiveâŚ"
"At Ayodhya, as many as fourteen trenches were laid out at different spots, one of which was the area known as the JanâŚ"
"In the mosque there are fourteen stone pillars some of which appear to be in position and oriented east-west and nortâŚ"
"The supporters of the Aryan-invasion theory have not been able to cite even a single example where is evidence of 'inâŚ"
"To put the tale synoptically. The Harappan cities collapsed, the civilization declined, but the people survived it alâŚ"