"Gilson criticizes attempts to trace Dante's position back to Thomism or Averroism. For St. Thomas, every hierarchy of dignity is at the same time a hierarchy of jurisdiction, while for Dante—except for God—a hierarchy of dignity is never the foundation of a hierarchy of jurisdiction, and this corresponds to Dante's specific philosophical problem, which is not so much to define the essence of philosophy as to determine functions and jurisdictions. The principle governing this determination is absolutely irreconcilable with Thomism. St. Thomas knows only one ultimate end: eternal bliss, which can only be attained through the Church; moreover, the spirituality of the ultimate end implies that between temporal and spiritual power there is a hierarchical subordination of the means to the end. For Dante, on the other hand, man can obtain, through the exercise of political virtues, a human happiness completely distinct from heavenly bliss, even if the latter represents a higher end. The thesis of the “duo ultima” legitimizes the complete distinction between the political order and the religious order, which is equally universal to that of the Church, but autonomous and pursuing an end of earthly happiness."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Augusto Del Noce, Gilson Étienne in Enciclopedia dantesca, vol. III, Roma, 1971, p. 33. Reported in 30Giorni.it, article n.° 13074
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Augusto_Del_Noce
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Augusto Del Noce
Augusto Del Noce (11 August 1910 – 30 December 1989) was an Italian philosopher and politician.
10 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Augusto Del Noce →
Related Quotes
"Of course, Catholics have a terrible habit: thinking about the power of modernity and ignoring how this modernity, in…"
"(About the book of Simone Weil entitled The Need for Roots) Of course, one cannot expect the formal perfection of oth…"
"(About Dante Alighieri) Of course, one cannot expect the formal perfection of other writings, but that is simply beca…"
"It is not that Dante intends to combat the cupiditas of the clergy in order to save the autonomy of the State; rather…"
"The hierarchy of dignity must not be confused with the hierarchy of jurisdiction. Such confusion, far from being homa…"
"The originality of Dante lies not so much in his affirmation of the autonomy of the state, but in the religious reaso…"
"[...] it is within the theology of original sin that the mutual autonomy of the Empire and the Church is understood."
"The theocratic ideal is based not only, as is often repeated, even by distinguished writers and by Maritain himself, …"
"These days, I am writing an introduction to Monarchia by Dante. It is a work that contains some very interesting insi…"
"However great this addition to the number of facts serving to elucidate the natural history of these most interesting…"