"It is sometimes desirable to have experimental data which is not completely precise. Had Berthollet been successful in convincing the chemical world that compounds do not have fixed proportions, the development of the atomic theory would have been greatly hindered. The fact that the Proust position became the accepted one in view of the work of Dalton, meant that the trials and errors toward a successful formulation of chemical compounds would ultimately succeed on the basis of an atomic philosophy. Once the atomic philosophy was clearly developed, the existence of the Berthollides could still be incorporated into chemical philosophy on the basis of studies of solid state physics. This illustrates clearly... the fact that science progresses from one state of approximation to another, and that progress may well be hindered when so much precise information is available that broad and useful concepts are overlooked."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Aaron J. Ihde, "On the Papers of Cyril Stanley Smith and Marie Boas," in Critical Problems in the History of Science (1959) ed. Marshall Clagett
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Atomic_theory
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Atomic theory
71 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Atomic theory →
Related Quotes
"We have come a long way from the classical ideal of objective descriptions. In quantum mechanics the departure from t…"
"Who sees the future? Let us have free scope for all directions of research; away with dogmatism, either atomistic or …"
"It seems not absurd to conceive that at the first Production of mixt Bodies, the Universal Matter whereof they among …"
"Neither is it impossible that of these minute Particles divers of the smallest and neighbouring ones were here and th…"
"I shall not peremptorily deny, that from most of such mixt Bodies as partake either of Animal or Vegetable Nature, th…"
"It may likewise be granted, that those distinct Substances, which Concretes generally either afford or are made up of…"
"And, to prevent mistakes, I must advertize You, that I now mean by Elements, as those Chymists that speak plainest do…"
"Fraunhofer's publication of 1814 did not receive prompt recognition, nor did his papers of 1821 and 1823. Physicists …"
"To try to make a model of an atom by studying its spectrum is like trying to make a model of a grand piano by listeni…"
"In 1763 a Croatian Jesuit named Roger Joseph Boscovich (1711 - 1787) identified the ultimate implication of this mech…"