"Furthermore, we are instructed, when we do come across instances of temple destruction, as in the case of Aurangzeb, we have to be circumspect in inferring what has happened and why.... the early monuments – like the Quwwat-ul-Islam mosque in Delhi – had to be built in ‘great haste’, we are instructed...Proclamation of political power, alone! And what about the religion which insists that religious faith is all, that the political cannot be separated from the religious? And the name: the Quwwat-ul-Islam mosque, the Might of Islam mosque? Of course, that must be taken to be mere genuflection! And notice: ‘available materials were assembled and incorporated’, they ‘clearly came from Hindu sources’ – may be the materials were just lying about; may be the temples had crumbled on their own earlier; may be the Hindus voluntarily broke their temples and donated the materials? No? After all, there is no proof they didn’t! And so, the word ‘plundered’ is repeatedly put within quotation marks! In fact, there is more. The use of such materials – from Hindu temples – for constructing Islamic mosques is part of ‘a process of architectural definition and accommodation by local workmen essential to the further development of a South Asian architecture for Islamic use’. The primary responsibility thus becomes that of those ‘local workmen’ and their ‘accommodation’. Hence, features in the Qutb complex come to ‘demonstrate a creative response by architects and carvers to a new programme’. A mosque that has clearly used materials, including pillars, from Hindu temples, in which undeniably ‘in the fabric of the central dome, a lintel carved with Hindu deities has been turned around so that its images face into the rubble wall’ comes ‘not to fix the rule’. ‘Rather, it stands in contrast to the rapid exploration of collaborative and creative possibilities – architectural, decorative, and synthetic – found in less fortified contexts.’ Conclusions to the contrary have been ‘misevaluations’. We are making the error of ‘seeing salvaged pieces’ – what a good word that, ‘salvaged ’: the pieces were not obtained by breaking down temples; they were lying as rubble and would inevitably have disintegrated with the passage of time; instead they were ‘salvaged ’, and given the honour of becoming part of new, pious buildings – ‘seeing salvaged pieces where healthy collaborative creativity was producing new forms’."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Arun_Shourie
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Arun Shourie
136 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Arun Shourie →
Related Quotes
"Then we have our seedy Leftists busy abusing each other. And finally we have the liberals - busy rearranging furnitur…"
"To rely on these fellows to save us from the impending fascist avalanche is to rely on superannuated buffaloes to see…"
"Thus silence retards reform. If large numbers were writing and talking about the communalism of these leaders, for in…"
"And yet I find in the majority judgement a fatal innocence... The judgement quotes the proclamations from the Rig, Ya…"
"The forfeiture is exactly the sort of thing which has landed us where we are : where intellectual inquiry is shut out…"
"They rely on intimidation, It is exactly by tactics of this kind that an earlier book of Mr. Swarup - Understanding I…"
"For fifty years this bunch has been suppressing facts and inventing lies. How concerned they are about that objective…"
"All the facts ... were well known fifty years ago. With the passing of the generation that fought for Independence, w…"
"The most telling illustration has been provided by the silence over the new archaeological findings. .... When the fi…"
"What we are witnessing today in relation to the criminals of the Emergency is not the rule of law but the destruction…"