"Animals themselves cannot plead their cause, and those who plead it for them have no obvious financial or other selfish interest in the issue, although many may have “vested” their emotions in it. When we turn to special gain from maintaining existing practices, special loss if they were to be changed, we find a large number of groups whose views might be discounted. Butchers, furriers, hunters, cattlemen, chicken farmers, scientific experimenters on animals would, unless compensated, all have to suffer significant personal loss if we were to change our practices. They cannot therefore be expected to see the moral issue without the distortion of special interest. The scientists might claim that in their case their own interest coincides with a universal human interest, but I think the butcher and the furrier could make a similar claim[.]"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
pp. 63-64
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Annette_Baier
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Annette Baier
Annette Claire Baier (née Stoop; 11 October 1929 – 2 November 2012) was a New Zealand philosopher and Hume scholar, focused in particular on Hume's moral psychology. She was well known also for her contributions to feminist philosophy and to the philosophy of mind, where she was strongly influenced by her former colleague, Wilfrid Sellars.
5 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Annette Baier →
Related Quotes
"One ground for suspicion of apparently sincere moral convictions is their link with some special interest of those wh…"
"I think there is at least one moral theory of respectable lineage and good independent credentials that can accommoda…"
"Animals can not disapprove, but they can complain and protest, at least until their vocal chords are cut to spare exp…"
"Hume describes (E, 235) as a “fancied monster” a man who has “no manner of concern to his fellow-creatures but to reg…"
"We might express this as "all persons are I" or rather as "you and I are the same person"."
"We must see that all places, times and conscious organisms are equally "this one". For a failure to see this must dis…"
"[T]here is only one way we can ever identify ourselves. That is through subjective experience. And subjective experie…"
"In all conscious life there is only one person—I—whose existence depends merely on the presence of a quality that is …"
"An experience must be a universal across times as well as across brains. This experience of being you, here now, woul…"
"Think about what you ordinarily would recognize to be 'these experiences', 'mine'. What makes them 'mine' for you? Is…"