"One of the central concepts for the understanding of ancient Greek mathematics has customarily been, at least since the time of and , the concept of 'geometric algebra'. What it amounts to is that Greek mathematics, especially after the discovery of the 'irrational'... is algebra dressed up, primarily for the sake of rigor, in geometrical garb. The reasoning... the line of attack... the solutions... etc. all are essentially algebraic... attired in geometrical accouterments. We... look for the algebraic 'subtext'... of any geometrical proof... always to transcribe... any proposition in[to] the symbolic language of modern algebra... [making] the logical structure of the proof clear and convincing, without thereby losing anything, not only in generality but also in any possible sui generis features of the ancient way of doing things. ...[i.e., that] there is nothing unique and (ontologically) idiosyncratic concerning the way... ancient Greek mathematicians went about their proofs, which might be lost... I cannot find any historically gratifying basis for this generally accepted view... those who have been writing the history of mathematics... have typically been mathematicians... largely unable to relinquish and discard their laboriously acquired mathematical competence when dealing with periods in history during which such competence is historically irrelevant and... anachronistic. Such... stems from the unstated assumption that mathematics is a scientia universalis, an algebra of thought containing universal ways of inference, everlasting structures, and timeless, ideal patterns of investigation which can be identified throughout the history of civilized man and which are completely independent of the form in which they happen to appear at a particular junction of time."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Sabetai Unguru, On the Need to Rewrite the History of Greek Mathematics, Archive for History of Exact Sciences, Vol. 15, No. 1, 30.XII (1975) pp. 67-114, as quoted, with Introduction in Classics in the History of Greek Mathematics (2004) ed. Jean Christianidis, pp. 386-390.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Ancient_Greek_mathematics
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Ancient Greek mathematics
Ancient was developed from the 7th century BC to the 4th century AD by Greek speaking peoples along the shores of the Eastern Mediterranean. The period following Alexander the Great is sometimes referred to as Hellenistic mathematics. The word "mathematics" itself derives from the ancient Greek μάθημα (mathema), meaning "subject of instruction". The use of generalized mathematical theories and proofs is the key difference between Greek mathematics and those of preceding civilizations.
57 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Ancient Greek mathematics →
Related Quotes
"Had the early Greek mind been sympathetic to the algebra and arithmetic of the Babylonians, it would have found plent…"
"The Greeks ordinarily are regarded as the founders of mathematics in the strict sense... for they emphasized the valu…"
"The Greek search for essences had led the Pythagoreans to picture the universe as a multitude of mathematical points …"
"That the discovery of incommensurability of lines made a strong impression on Greek thought is indicated by the story…"
"In mathematics... the Greek attitude differed sharply from that of the earlier potamic cultures. The contrast was cle…"
"In the Greek world mathematics was more closely related to philosophy than to practical affairs, and this kinship has…"
"These three problems—the , the duplication of the cube, and the trisection of the angle—have since been known as the …"
"Comparatively few of the propositions and proofs in the Elements are his [Euclid's] own discoveries. In fact, the pro…"
"Euclid, Archimedes, and Apollonius brought geometry to as high a state of perfection as it perhaps could be brought w…"
"If the early Greeks were cognizant of Babylonian algebra, they made no attempt to develop or even to use it, and ther…"