"Despite the author’s commitment to universalism, Carl Ritter’s Vorhalle (1819) already looked in this direction. In this text, Ritter speculated that a prehistorical diaspora had pushed peoples from northern India westward, laying the foundations for European civilization. To demonstrate that the Black Sea kingdom of Colchis, mythical home of Medea and destination of the Argonauts, was not an Egyptian, but an Indian settlement, he depended partly upon physical characteristics, arguing that the Colchians’ facial features and hair were different from those of the Egyptians, though both were, according to Herodotus, dark- skinned.©® Ritter insisted that the Indians, Persians, Germanic tribes, Scandinavians, Greeks, and Scythians shared a ‘“‘common root” as well as a kind of primeval monotheism, commonalities that made them more like one another than were some groups who shared spaces contemporaneously, like the Romans and Etruscans, or those who shared it over time, such as ancient and modern Indians. Ritter was not too worried about dark-skinned Indian ancestors, but as the British extended more and more control over the subcontinent, this relationship between modern — “fallen” — Indians and idealized ancient Indians began to become more problematic. Increasingly pervasive was the view that India was not the homeland of the Aryans, but rather the place where Aryans had mixed with darker others, instigating the cultural decline and weakness that would characterize Indian history ever afterward. Those who elaborated this view included A. W. Schlegel, Christian Lassen, Theodor Benfey, and C. F. Koeppen.” That these leading Indologists spent so much time, and spilled so much ink, in discussing this subject confirms the field’s sense that this was not only a crucially important issue, but also one for which a variety of difficult-to-interpret sources needed to be read to yield essentially the same results.” If these scholars used “race” in varying ways, clearly it was becoming a more prominent, and meaningful, part of the study of the ancient Orient."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
University of Chicago alumniPrinceton University facultyUniversity of California, Berkeley alumniLouisiana State University faculty21st-century American historians
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Suzanne_L._Marchand
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Suzanne L. Marchand
12 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Suzanne L. Marchand →
Related Quotes
"Though generated by thoroughly western rivalries and concerns, invoking the Orient has often been the means by which …"
"Here, however, I will argue that the cultural politics of Orientalistik were defined much less by ‘“‘modern” concerns…"
"I have been forced to conclude that German orientalism — defined as the serious and sustained study of the cultures o…"
"There were travel accounts and anthropological disquisitions; there were histories of philosophy and a bumper crop of…"
"..Iamblichus, Pausanias, Plotinus, and Strabo, scholars who wrote in times of relative Greek insecurity vis-a-vis the…"
"But Creuzer was also a product of his age and its aspirations; like Friedrich Schlegel, he was seeking a supra-confes…"
"This opened the way, as Partha Mitter has argued, for Hegel’s insight that since art represented not reality but some…"
"Though they tended to religious radicalism and political liberalism, most mid-century orientalists did not, as had Mo…"
"But the “furious” generation did not want to tarry in positivist particularism, for they thought they now had the mat…"
"What a large number did, however, have in common was the longing to return to subjects left fallow by mid-century sch…"