"I agree with Mr Wolf that freedom is centrally important. But how should we see the demands of freedom when habit-forming behaviour today restricts the freedom of the same person in the future? Once acquired, the habit of smoking is hard to kick, and it can be asked, with some plausibility, whether youthful smokers have an unqualified right to place their future selves in such bondage. A similar issue was addressed by the leading apostle of liberty, John Stuart Mill, when he argued against a person’s freedom to sell himself or herself in slavery. […] Another question to ask is: who exactly are the “others” who are affected? Passive smokers are not the only people who might be harmed. If smokers are made ill by their decision to go on smoking, then the society can either take the view that these victims of self-choice have no claim to public resources (such as the National Health Service or social safety nets), or more leniently (and I believe more reasonably) it could accept that these people still qualify to get social help. If the former, we would live in a monstrously unforgiving society; and happily I do not see Britain or France going that way. If the latter, then the interests of “others” would surely be affected through the sharing of the costs of public services."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Amartya Sen, "Unrestrained smoking is a libertarian half-way house", Financial Times (February 11, 2007)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Smoking_ban
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Smoking ban
2 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Smoking ban →
Related Quotes
"I am opposed to any such policy. I am merely pointing out the absurdities of current plans. Harm to others is a neces…"
"The ' measures the volume of s compared to the total (red blood cells and ). The normal hematocrit for men is 40 to 5…"
"is the packed spun volume of whole that is made up of s and is expressed as a percentage of total . It can be measure…"
"A leaflet drops through your letter box advising on ways to avoid contracting and spreading . Your bag is searched as…"
"The secure and continuous production of and are key to U.S. national security. The introduction of foreign-origin or …"
"In a strict sense, biosecurity involves issues dealing directly with s and s, such as prevention of emergence, loss, …"
"When most physicians are asked about the realm of biosecurity, they often are able to discuss the subject in broad st…"
"Unfortunately, all organs, with the exception of corneas, have this unfortunate characteristic: in order to be transp…"
"When you transplant a heart from a baboon into a baby as we did, and you say the body of that baby is sacred, does th…"
"The truth is that the definition of brain death was proposed by Harvard Medical School in the summer of 1968, a few m…"