"Even if Melissus’s analysis of the concept of existence is faulty, his procedure is very interesting. He challenges the data of sense experience by appealing to conceptual truths, facts about what a certain predicate (here ‘true’) must entail. These facts seem to escape the need to appeal to sense experience. We check up what is true about being true by examining our notion of being true, not by checking any things in the external world. So the argument seems to find a way of challenging the value of sense experience without begging the question. Melissus casts doubt on the senses by privileging the logical grammar of the word ‘true’. But, we might ask, did we learn how to use the word ‘true’ without relying on the senses?"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
University of Cambridge alumniPhilosophers from EnglandUniversity of Cambridge facultyGreen Party of England and Wales politiciansMembers of the European Parliament
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Catherine_Rowett
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Catherine Rowett
22 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Catherine Rowett →
Related Quotes
"Much of the content of so-called Pythagorean teaching appears to be a mix of mystical gobble-de-gook and adulatory ve…"
"In the Protagoras Socrates persuades Protagoras that goodness is identical with pleasure. He advocates a form of hedo…"
"For Heraclitus, the logos is something that we need to learn to notice if we are to understand the true significance …"
"Philosophy has come to include, for us, a wide range of theoretical questions that typically look beyond what we can …"
"Sophistry is one of the methods by which politicians dress up their policies in alien clothing, to pass them off as m…"
"As the Presocratic philosophers bow out and Plato arrives to direct the next drama in the series, the Sophists make a…"
"Both Democritus and Anaxagoras try to explain the puzzling behaviour of ordinary reality by appeal to a microscopic r…"
"Plato’s metaphysics grew out of that of Parmenides, together with a strong feel for Heraclitus’s account of the physi…"
"Perhaps Heraclitus lived before Parmenides, perhaps he lived after, perhaps he lived at the same time. Whichever way,…"
"Are these good reasons for worrying about the apparent contradiction? Should either make us feel the need of an expla…"