"QUESTION: Is there any statute in Texas that prohibits the doctor from performing any operation other than an abortion? MR. FLOWERS I don’t – I don’t think so, sir, and there is another thrust of our argument. If we declare, as the appellees in this case have asked this Court to declare, that an embryo or a fetus is a mass of protoplasm similar to a tumor, then, of course, the State has no compelling interest whatsoever. QUESTION: But there is no – the only operation that a doctor can possibly commit that will bring on a criminal penalty is an abortion? MR. FLOWERS: Yes, sir. QUESTION: Why? MR. FLOWERS: As far as – 'QUESTION: Well, why don’t you limit some other operations? MR. FLOWERS: Because this is the only type of operation that would take another human life. QUESTION: Well, a brain operation could. MR. FLOWERS: Well, there again, that would be – I think that in every feat that a doctor performs that he is constantly making this judgment. QUESTION: Well, if a doctor performs a brain operation and doe it improperly, he could be guilty of manslaughter, couldn’t he? MR. FLOWERS: I would think so, if he was negligent. QUESTION: Well, why couldn’t you charge him with manslaughter if he commits an abortion? MR. FLOWERS: In effect, Your Honor, we did. In the statute 1195, that has been very carefully avoided all throughout these proceeding, it’s not attacked as unconstitutional, for some reason."
Roe v. Wade

January 1, 1970

Quote Details

Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Added on April 10, 2026
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English

Sources

pp.27-28

https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Roe_v._Wade