"Thor involved a prison physician petitioning the court to allow him to force-feed a quadriplegic patient who had decided to die. Id. The court considered four state interests: preserving life; preventing suicide; maintaining the integrity of the medical profession; and protecting innocent third parties. Id., at 737, 21 Cal.Rptr.2d 357, 855 P.2d 375. Finally, the court considered how this would affect orderly administration of the prison system. Id., at 744, 21 Cal.Rptr.2d 357, 855 P.2d 375. In considering the first four factors, the court, noted that this patient was quadriplegic and serving a life sentence; the patient's decision to refuse medical treatment was an informed decision, and there were no other persons involved in this decision. Id., at 743-44, 21 Cal.Rptr.2d 357, 855 P.2d 375. Finally, the state had presented no evidence on the effect this would have on administration of the prison system. Id., at 745, 21 Cal.Rptr.2d 357, 855 P.2d 375. The third case prohibiting state interference with a prisoner's hunger strike is from Florida. The inmate went on a hunger strike to protest his transfer to a different prison and to protest the lodging of complaints against a prison chaplain. Singletary v. Costello, 665 So.2d 1099, 1101 (Fla.App.1996). The court first recognized a strong interest in the inmate's rights to privacy and to refuse medical treatment. Id., at 1104. The court then weighed the state's interests in preserving life, preventing suicide, protecting third parties, maintaining the ethics of the medical profession, and maintaining order in the prison. Id., at 1105. On the facts of the case, the court stated that "although the state interest in the preservation of life is powerful, in and of itself, it will not foreclose a competent person from declining life-sustaining medical treatment.... This is because the life that the state is seeking to protect is the life of the same person who has competently decided to [forgo] the medical intervention." (Citation omitted.) Id., at 1109. The court found it important, also, that the prisoner had expressly stated that he did not want to die, meaning that the state's interest in preventing suicide was not implicated. Id. Finally, no evidence was offered on the other factors; therefore, the court denied the state's petition."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
p.172
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Force-feeding
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Force-feeding
120 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Force-feeding →
Related Quotes
"The American Medical Association and the Red Cross both condemn force-feeding as a form of torture. And yet, the U.S.…"
"1914 New York World magazine article. Barnes wrote, "If I, play acting, felt my being burning with revolt at this bru…"
"In 2013, a mass hunger strike took place in Guantanamo Bay as a response to the indefinite detention and unjust treat…"
"Dec. 30, 2005 – At least 46 people held at the Guantánamo Bay, Cuba detention camp joined a disputed number of fellow…"
"A man jailed in the US for trying to blow up an airliner with explosives hidden in his shoes has gone on hunger strik…"
"A government lawyer said that Reid had refused 58 meals by 9 April and that prison officials decided "that medical in…"
"Six weeks into his hunger strike, Israel's parliament passed a law permitting the force-feeding of prisoners in order…"
"Romanos has not been charged with terrorism. But two cases concerning terrorism acts are still pending — a fact that …"
"When federal prison officials at British Columbia’s Matsqui Psychiatric Centre routinely examined a Doukhobor woman o…"
"Since President Obama mentioned Supermax in a speech about Guantanamo, we wanted to take you there again. It's a sort…"