"In the long debate about action at a distance versus contact action we also find a concern with the effective individuation of particles and subsystems and with distant action. Belief in contact action goes back to Aristotle and Eudoxes, based on the self-evident regulative principle that a thing cannot act where it is not. For them, causal explanations were essential for true science. For Descartes too, there could be no vacuum and what may appear to be empty is actually filled with an aether. After the Principia, there were basically two camps on the "gravity dilemma." The one, among whose members were the Cartesians, Leibniz, and Huygens, maintained that an ether was required to allow any intelligible explanation of gravitational phenomena. The other, notably represented by Newton's ally... , took gravity to be evidence for God's action. ...God is everywhere and, hence, "instantaneous" action... is no mystery. The basic motivating factor in demanding contact action was that of intelligibility. Maxwell put the matter quite succinctly when he argued for "a force of the old school—a case of vis a tergo—a shove from behind."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
, Quantum Mechanics: Historical Contingency and the Copenhagen Hegemony (1994) p. 19.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Principle_of_locality
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Principle of locality
17 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Principle of locality →
Related Quotes
"[C]onsider the scalar ... the change in the electrons' interference pattern is a nonlocal effect of the electric fiel…"
"For several centuries, there has been a strong feeling that nonlocal theories are not acceptable in physics. ...Newto…"
"Frans van Luteren (1991), in his extensive... study of conceptions of gravity in the eighteenth and nineteenth centur…"
"Classical electrodynamics is generally understood to be the paradigm of a local and causal physical theory. ...[A] th…"
"To soothe the theologians, who in his time were pressing so hardly upon Galileo, Descartes was content to say that th…"
"[L]ocality... reflects our ability to construct the "big picture" like a jigsaw puzzle, starting with a description o…"
"In fact every theory in the history of physics before quantum theory was EPR-local. So the discovery that the world i…"
"I must ask you to go over very old ground, and to turn your attention to a question which has been raised again and a…"
"The generation that grew up with Newtonian gravity found the theory entirely natural. For millennia, natural philosop…"
"Descartes' objective was comprehensibility—to make the workings of nature completely transparent. Locality was essent…"