"Equality gives rise to challenging questions which are not altogether easy to answer... a = a and a = b are obviously statements of differing cognitive value; a = a holds a priori and, according to Kant, is to be labeled analytic, while statements of the form a = b often contain very valuable extensions of our knowledge and cannot always be established a priori. The discovery that the rising sun is not new every morning, but always the same, was one of the most fertile astronomical discoveries. Even to-day the identification of a small planet or a comet is not always a matter of course. Now if we were to regard equality as a relation between that which the names 'a' and 'b' designate, it would seem that a = b could not differ from a = a (i.e. provided a = b is true). A relation would thereby be expressed of a thing to itself, and indeed one in which each thing stands to itself but to no other thing."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
As cited in: M. Fitting, Richard L. Mendelsoh (1999), First-Order Modal Logic, p. 142. They called this Frege's Puzzle.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Gottlob_Frege
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Related Quotes
"'Facts, facts, facts,' cries the scientist if he wants to emphasize the necessity of a firm foundation for science. W…"
"It really is worth the trouble to invent a new symbol if we can thus remove not a few logical difficulties and ensure…"
"A judgment, for me is not the mere grasping of a thought, but the admission of its truth."
"Ein Philosoph, der keine Beziehung zur Geometrie hat, ist nur ein halber Philosoph, und ein Mathematiker, der keine p…"
"If the task of philosophy is to break the domination of words over the human mind [...], then my concept notation, be…"
"This ideography is a "formula language", that is, a lingua characterica, a language written with special symbols, "fo…"
"I hope I may claim in the present work to have made it probable that the laws of arithmetic are analytic judgments an…"
"Nur im Zusammenhange eines Satzes bedeuten die Wörter etwas. Es wird also darauf ankommen, den Sinn eines Satzes zu e…"
"Your discovery of the contradiction caused me the greatest surprise and, I would almost say, consternation, since it …"
"If I compare arithmetic with a tree that unfolds upward into a multitude of techniques and theorems while its root dr…"