"What do you think of using UML to generate implementation code? James: I think it’s a terrible idea. I know that I disagree with many other UML experts, but there is no magic about UML. If you can generate code from a model, then it is programming language. And UML is not a well-designed programming language. The most important reason is that it lacks a well-defined point of view, partly by intent and partly because of the tyranny of the OMG standardization process that tries to provide everything to everybody. It doesn't have a well-defined underlying set of assumptions about memory, storage, concurrency, or almost anything else. How can you program in such a language? The fact is that UML and other modelling language are not meant to be executable. The point of models is that they are imprecise and ambiguous. This drove many theoreticians crazy so they tried to make UML "precise", but models are imprecise for a reason: we leave out things that have a small effect so we can concentrate on the things that have big or global effects. That's how it works in physics models: you model the big effect (such as the gravitation from the sun) and then you treat the smaller effects as perturbation to the basic model (such as the effects of the planets on each other). If you tried to solve the entire set of equations directly in full detail, you couldn't do anything."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
James Rumbaugh in Federico Biancuzzi and Shane Warden eds. (2009) Masterminds of Programming. p. 339
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Executable_UML
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Executable UML
24 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Executable UML →
Related Quotes
"Originally UML was intended to serve as a . But a specification is primarily intended to describe properties of syste…"
"The (UML) is a general-purpose visual that is used to specify, visualize, construct, and document the artifacts of a …"
"I assume that a precisely defined, verifiable, executable, and translatable UML is a Good Thing and leave it to other…"
"In its current form UML is designed to support a wide variety of different modelling techniques and formalisms. This …"
"The use of UML collaboration diagrams for specifying complex real-time architectures has been the focus of some recen…"
"The use of UML techniques in TRADE has implications for the semantics of these techniques when they are used this way…"
"Ever wish you could draw a few diagrams, press a button, and have a working software system that meets your needs? So…"
"In my opinion this sounds great in theory, but unfortunately there are several problems to making this work in practice:"
":I have no doubt that we will begin to see some interesting tools emerge over the next few years based on the Executa…"
"Today some evidence arises that UML will more and more be used not as a but as a high level programming language. Thi…"