"There is this difference between The Conquest of New Spain and the Chachnama. Bernal Díaz, the Spaniard, was writing of events he had taken part in. The Chachnama is Arab or Muslim genre writing, a “pleasant story of conquest,” and it was written five hundred years after the conquest of Sind. The author was Persian; his source was an Arabic manuscript preserved by the family of the conqueror, Bin Qasim. The intervening five centuries have added no extra moral or historical sense to the Persian narrative, no new wonder or compassion, no idea of what is cruel and what is not cruel, such as even Bernal Díaz, the Spanish soldier, possesses. To the Persian, writing in 1216, the Arab conquests—“the conquests of Khurasan, Ajam [Persia], Iraq, Sham [Syria], Rum [Byzantium] and Hind”—are glorious; they are the story of the spread of true civilization. Conquest is pleasant to read about because conquest is “based on spiritual rectitude and temporal excellence ... of which learned philosophers and generous kings would be proud, because all men attain advancement to perfection by acknowledging as true the belief of the people of Arabia.” There is an irony in this praise of conquest: not many years after those words were written, the invading Mongols were to arrive in Persia and Iraq, and the Arab civilization which the Chachnama celebrated was to be shattered, stupefied for centuries."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Naipaul, V. S. (1981). Among the believers: An Islamic journey. New York: Knopf.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Chach_Nama
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Chach Nama
31 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Chach Nama →
Related Quotes
"[Division of Plunder] Then all the great and principal inhabitants of the city assembled together, and silver to the …"
"The Chachnama is in many ways like The Conquest of New Spain by Bernal Díaz del Castillo, the Spanish soldier who in …"
"[The flight of the chief of Dhalila] When the day dawned through the veil of darkness Muhammad Kasim learnt that they…"
"[Muhammad Kasim fights with the ferry-men] That day the battle raged from morning till sun-set and when the world, li…"
"[Reflection of Muhammad Kasim] Muhammad Kasim thought it might perhaps be a man, so he drew his sword to strike it; b…"
"As a result, the Chachnama records, “some [Hindus] resolved to live in their native land, but others took flight in o…"
""The Chachnama is Arab or Muslim genre writing, a `pleasant story of conquest,' the conquest of Sindh. But it is a bl…"
"[Battle of Bahrur and Dhalila] Muhammad Kasim now determined to march to Brahmanabad. Between Dawar and that city the…"
"[Conquest of Sikka Multan by Muhammad Kasim] When he had settled affairs with Kaksa, he left the fort, crossed the Bi…"
"The Chachnama shows the Arabs of the seventh century as a people stimulated and enlightened and disciplined by Islam,…"