Hermann Hankel

"The first writer to attribute this proposition to Pythagoras is Vitruvius, hardly a reliable witness. From then on, this account became more widespread, but always in connection with the famous hecatomb that Pythagoras is said to have offered in celebration of discovering the proposition—an anecdote that severely undermines the credibility of the entire story. This sacrifice is incompatible with the strict prohibition of all bloody sacrifices, which writers of the same period, indeed often the very same ones who elsewhere recount the hecatomb, have handed down to us from the Pythagorean ritual laws. Cicero himself took offense at this anecdote, and in the latest Neopythagorean tradition, the bloody sacrifice is replaced by that of an ox formed from flour. For this reason, the hecatomb is not only incongruous with the Pythagoreans, but also with the Pythagoreans themselves. Proclus, an insightful writer, expresses himself remarkably vaguely: ‘When we listen to those who want to tell old stories, we find that they trace this theorem back to Pythagoras.’ As this shows, he too was unaware of any reliable source."