"What is the difference between Caste and Varna as understood by the Mahatma? I find none. As defined by the Mahatma, Varna becomes merely a different name for Caste for the simple reason that it is the same in essence—namely pursuit of ancestral calling. Far from making progress the Mahatma has suffered retrogression. By putting this interpretation upon the Vedic conception of Varna he has really made ridiculous what was sublime. While I reject the Vedic Varnavyavastha for reasons given in the speech I must admit that the Vedic theory of Varna as interpreted by Swami Dayanand and some others is a sensible and an inoffensive thing. It did not admit birth as a determining factor in fixing the place of an individual in society. It only recognized worth. The Mahatma’s view of Varna not only makes nonsense of the Vedic Varna but it makes it an abominable thing. Varna and Caste are two very different concepts. Varna is based on the principle of each according to his worth-while Caste is based on the principle of each according to his birth. The two are as distinct as chalk is from cheese. In fact there is an antithesis between the two. If the Mahatma believes as he does in every one following his or her ancestral calling, then most certainly he is advocating the Caste System and that in calling it the Varna System he is not only guilty of terminologicale inexactitude, but he is causing confusion worse confounded. I am sure that all his confusion is due to the fact that the Mahatma has no definite and clear conception as to what is Varna and what is Caste and as to the necessity of either for the conservation of Hinduism."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar, Annihilation of Caste
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Varna_(Hinduism)
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Varna (Hinduism)
13 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Varna (Hinduism) →
Related Quotes
"This evidence from the Zenda Avesta as to the meaning of the word Varna leaves no doubt that it originally meant a cl…"
"The true conclusion to be drawn from the Rig Veda is not that the Varna system did not exist, but that there were onl…"
"It has, at any rate, been an extremely consequential mistake. That white Aryan invaders defeated black aboriginal res…"
"In my opinion, the semantic development has passed through varna, "colour", in the sense of "one in a spectrum", with…"
"[Trautmann likewise points out that there is no contextual evidence supporting the nontraditional interpretation of v…"
"G.C. Pande, the noted Sanskrit scholar, says that only the Dharmashastra in the post-Vedic period started to pervert …"
"Discussing the early Vedic period, V.M. Apte says that the Rig Veda refers to the varnas in a way that cannot be cons…"
"The case for color as a dominant factor in the development of caste was not supported by the evidence of historical l…"
"In that connection, the reading of varna, ‘colour, social class’, as referring to skin colour, was upheld as proof of…"
"The idea is that all varnas are contained in every individual, instead of every individual being comprised within one…"