"In the years immediately after World War II, Marshall (1947), Shils and Janowitz (1948), and Stouffer et al. (1949) argued that social cohesion within the soldier’s primary group is essential to military effectiveness. Shils and Janowitz offered the following (1948, p. 281): It appears that a soldier’s ability to resist is a function of the capacity of his immediate primary group (his squad or section) to avoid social disintegration. When the individual’s immediate group, and its supporting formations, met his basic organic needs, offered him affection and esteem from both officers and comrades, supplied him with a sense of power and adequately regulated his relations with authority, the element of self-concern in battle, which would lead to disruption of the effective functioning of his primary group, was minimized. Nevertheless, it is not clear that social cohesion was the driving force behind combat motivation, even during World War II. Stouffer et al. (1949) reported that when soldiers were asked, “What was most important to you in making you want to keep going and do as well as you could?” only 14 percent cited “solidarity with the group”; the most popular response (cited by 39 percent) was “ending the task.”"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Ibid, p.144.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Unit_cohesion
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Unit cohesion
14 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Unit cohesion →
Related Quotes
"When I was bleeding to death in my Black Hawk helicopter after I was shot down, I didn't care if the American troops …"
"Only when both social and task cohesion were low did people rate overall cohesion as low. The negative effects of too…"
"In the years immediately after World War II, several scholars argued, based on information collected from German and …"
"The post-Vietnam–era military scholars began articulating a view of cohesion that emphasizes the importance of task c…"
"Siebold (2007) describes the “standard model” of cohesion as involving peer (horizontal), leader (vertical), organiza…"
"In their interviews with members of the Army, Navy, and Marines regarding the integration of women in units, Harrell …"
"In the theater of operations . . . the presence of the enemy, and his capacity to injure and kill, give the dominant …"
"Elsewhere, Moskos, as cited in Marlowe (1979), referred to this social compact as “instrumental and self-serving.” Bu…"
"Several recent studies have examined the effects of race, ethnicity, and gender on military cohesion. Siebold and Lin…"
"Joshi and Roh note that their analysis helps to pinpoint “the specific conditions under which diversity can have bene…"