"I am not alone in making this point. At least one European Indologist accuses Pollock of relocating Orientalism 'to the "New Raj" across the deep blue sea'... He [Grünendahl] says Pollock's narrative 'is not an evidence-based study of Orientalism or Indology in Germany, but a sophisticated charge of anti-Semitism based largely on trumped-up "evidence".... Pollock's post-Orientalist messianism would have us believe that only late twentieth-century (and now twenty-first century) America is intellectually equipped to reject and finally overcome [‘Eurocentrism’...] The path from the 'Deep Orientalism' of old to a new 'Indology beyond the Raj and Auschwitz' leads to the 'New Raj' across the deep blue sea.... Thus, Grünendahl has noted Pollock's tendency to develop broad narratives without any supporting evidence. Moreover, he draws attention to Pollock's messianism in promoting American scholarship.... , casting doubt on Pollock's attempt to analyse Sanskrit objectively. He raises the pertinent question as to whether Pollock is providing the intellectual foundations for America's 'New Raj', to replace the dead British Raj - i.e., whether American imperialism is replacing the dead British imperialism."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesTranslators from the United StatesHarvard University alumniLinguists from the United StatesIndologists
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Grünendahl cited in Rajiv Malhotra, The Battle for Sanskrit (2016)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Sheldon_Pollock
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Sheldon Pollock
Sheldon I. Pollock (born February 16 1948) is a scholar of Sanskrit, the intellectual and literary history of India, and comparative intellectual history. He is currently the Arvind Raghunathan Professor of South Asian Studies at the Department of Middle Eastern, South Asian, and African Studies at Columbia University. He was the general editor of the Clay Sanskrit Library and is the founding editor of the Murty Classical Library of India.
21 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Sheldon Pollock →
Related Quotes
"There is nothing remarkable about the people in premodern South Asia having a clear and accurate conception of the sp…"
"“How, concretely, does one do Indology beyond the Raj and Auschwitz in a world of pretty well tattered scholarly para…"
"“An example of this more sophisticated orientalism is the work of Paul Thieme”... esp. his “analysis of the Sanskrit …"
"“Moving beyond orientalism finally presupposes moving beyond the culture of domination and the politics of coercion t…"
"“In German Indology of the NS era, a largely nonscholarly mystical nativism deriving ultimately from a mixture of rom…"
"“The Ŗg-Veda as an Aryan text ‘free of any taint of Semitic contact’; the ‘almost Nordic zeal’ that lies in the Buddh…"
"“From among the complexities of NS analysis of the Urheimat question it is worth calling attention to the way the nin…"
"... there exist no good accounts or theorizations of the end of the cultural order that for two millennia exerted a t…"
"For one thing, Sanskrit literary culture was never affected by communicative incompetence, which began to enfeeble La…"
"The Veda, the transcendent śāstra, subsumes all knowledge."