"Normal science is work aimed at extending and refining the paradigm. A good normal scientist is committed to the paradigm and does not question it. Normal scientists extend their paradigm both theoretically and experimentally. Anomalies inevitably arise, however, and eventually these reach a kind of critical mass, at which point scientists lose faith in the paradigm and the field plunges into a state of crisis. … One problem comes from Kuhn’s insistence that, except in unusual cases, a scientific field has one paradigm per field per time. … Secondly, Kuhn exaggerates the degree of commitment that a normal scientist does and should have to a paradigm. Kuhn describes the attitude of a normal scientist in very strong terms. Scientific education is a kind of “indoctrination,” which results in scientists having a deep “faith” in their paradigm. As a description of how science actually works, this seems exaggerated. Sometimes there is a faithlike commitment, but sometimes there is not. Many scientists are able to say that they always work within a paradigm, for practical reasons, while being very aware of the possibility of error and the eventual replacement of their framework. One of the ironies of Kuhn’s influence is that his book might have weakened the faith of some normal scientists, even though Kuhn thought that normal scientists should have a deep faith in their paradigms!"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Peter Godfrey-Smith, Theory and Reality: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Science (2003), Chap. 5 : Kuhn and Normal Science
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Normal_science
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Normal science
5 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Normal science →
Related Quotes
"Kuhn used the phrase “normal science” for scientific work that occurs within the framework provided by a paradigm. A …"
"For a current illustration of what is absolutely right, and also of what is questionable, in Kuhn’s idea of normal sc…"
"In my view the ‘normal’ scientist, as Kuhn describes him, is a person one ought to be sorry for. (According to Kuhn’s…"
"It was not Kuhn's description of scientific revolutions that impressed me so much when I first read Structure in 1972…"
"The transformation of a compound into another substance, or... substances, through... heat alone is... pyrolysis."
"[T]he great majority of pyrolyses occur at "high" temperatures, but this only means... familiarity with compounds whi…"
"Flash pyrolysis has the potential of producing maximum yields of gases and liquids from coal and organic solid wastes…"
"Fire, as the agent for , was a favorite tool of the alchemist. Although the general prevalence... of pyrolysis has lo…"
"Frequently, pyrolyses are s, but... "Pyrolysis" is... broader... [and] more concise. In "decompositions", there is...…"
"Some compounds decompose at the temperature of boiling water... others require red heat. ...[C]ompounds may be stable…"