"Sharma also focused strongly on bringing in a stage of feudalism on European model in the post-Gupta period. Sharma’s feudalism theory falls through for many clear reasons. The land-grant inscriptions of the kind Sharma mentions continue to occur in Rajasthan till the 17th/18th century and in the dynastic contexts mentioned by Sharma their number over a period of about 400 years is reputedly no more than 33, an insignificant number to build up an all-India stage of development. What is also ignored is the fact that such grants of land to Brahmins fall in line with a well-known Hindu ritual behaviour of granting Brahmins land on auspicious days after taking ritual bath. More importantly, KP Jayaswal demonstrated in Hindu Polity that the kings of ancient India were not the owners of the kingdom’s land. This land belonged to the individual owners. Many 19th century British administrators also supported this contention. The point is that the kings of ancient India did not have the legal right to distribute lands among a separate class of retainers and thus it was impossible for them to generate a class of feudal barons based on such donations. In the writings of Sharma’s associates, one notes the use of such terms as ‘early mediaeval’, ‘state formation’ and ‘legitimisation’ (of monarchy). The term ‘early mediaeval’ has been loosely used for a long time but the basic politics of this use in recent times is to suggest the existence of an ‘early mediaeval’ Hindu India merging smoothly into the ‘mediaeval’ Muslim India, thus obviating the drastic difference between the two."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Chakrabarti, D. K. (2021). Nationalism in the study of ancient Indian history. National Security, 4(1), 29-50.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Indian_feudalism
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Indian feudalism
2 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Indian feudalism →
Related Quotes
"[Karashima] cautions against the ‘mechanical application of the concept of feudalism in the South Indian context as h…"
"A report by Time Magazine (dated 30th June 1980) read, “In the worst massacre, in the village of Mandai, the tribals …"
"Now compare this with the attitude of the BBC during the Kargil war. Most of us foreign correspondents know by now th…"
"Ex-Mandai MLA recounted, Manoranjan Debbarma. “Children were spiked to death and wombs of pregnant women were ripped …"
"Major R. Rajamani, the commander of the Indian Army unit that reached Mandai on 9th June 1980, compared the brutality…"
"During the winter of 1998/99, Pakistanis had stealthily occupied several Himalayan mountain peaks on the Indian side.…"
"Your two letters, with the enclosed memorandums of the Nâimâ (Nair) captives, have been received. You did right in ca…"
"Getting possession of the villain, Goorkul, and of his wife and children, you must forcibly make Mussalmans out of th…"
"With hostilities having ceased for now, the sepoys and officers were seen loitering around the vanquished capital. So…"
"After taking and defending the town, the British armies now laid siege to the strong fort of Bangalore on 7 March 179…"