"The existence of trans people ought to make everyone take a long hard look at their own dearly held ideas about gender, and wonder whether these ideas are quite as stable and certain as they once thought. This would be healthy. The distinction between men and women is often arbitrary. The distinction between ‘binary’ trans men and women and non-binary trans people is equally arbitrary and, in reality, the precise distinction between people we call cis and people we call trans isn’t rigid either. The fact that definitions can be so unstable is clearly deeply troubling to many – which is why it is easier to belittle challenges to binaries than to take on their contradictions, complications and exceptions. ‘We are all non-binary’ is potentially a radical new analysis for how we might reorder society, but conventionally it is used by gender critical feminists to mock those people making political demands to dismantle the binary’s imprint on our culture. Yet those critics provide no alternative for how we would otherwise emancipate society from binary gender stereotypes and roles. Once more, feminist hostility to non-binary people reasserts the notion of an inescapable biological sex that should be given more social and legal credence than a variant gender identity, a notion that merely replicates patriarchy’s own logic."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Shon Faye, : An Argument for Justice |date=2021 |publisher=Allen Lane |isbn=978-0-241-42314-1}} Chapter Seven
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Gender-critical_feminism
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Gender-critical feminism
6 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Gender-critical feminism →
Related Quotes
"There are some who hold onto rigid ideas of biological sex, but I do not expect feminists to be among them. When I he…"
"Anti-trans feminists’ repeated claims that they were being silenced were in fact highly effective in getting their vi…"
"The way we are all taught, from a young age, to make the link between visible biological sex traits and behaviour can…"
"Feminism must concern itself with radical possibilities for our future, a future in which gender-based violence and h…"
"TERF ... has expanded to include any woman worried that permitting men who “self-identify” as female to enter women’s…"
"By the mid-seventeenth century, depictions of s, animals, and plants had officially been declassed to the status of i…"
"The work of women artists, which often transgresses the racial, ethnic, and gender dictates of society, asks us to co…"
"We know little of the practice of the arts by women in ancient times. The degraded condition of the sex in Eastern co…"
"After studying the optical effects of the , in 1960 began to make the extremely precise pictures for which she is kno…"
"Why, yes, of course I wrote all the Arab of Mesopotamia. I've loved the reviews which speak of the practical men who …"