"Perhaps the hallmark of late twentieth-century critical legal studies (CLS) writing was the claim that this widely made inference from consent to value is simply unwarranted. People’s abilities to ascertain and act on their own self-interest are limited, the critical scholars argued. The capacity of countries, institutions, multinational corporations, social forces, or simply stronger parties to create in individual subjects a willingness to consent to transactions or changes that do not in fact increase their well being is well documented. “Consent” of the weaker can be manufactured to serve the interests of dominant parties, and when it is manufactured, it is not a good measure of the value to the weak of that to which consent was given. Neither skepticism regarding the good motives or knowledge base of the “paternalist,” nor faith in the self-regarding preferences of the individual, justify the unexamined inference that a consensual change so extracted is a good one for all affected parties. The degree to which a consensual change is perceived as such is the degree to which it has been unduly legitimated by the consent that preceded it. The legitimation cost of consensual transactions, then, is the sometimes unwarranted belief in the increased value of the change to which consent was proffered."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
West R (2009). “From Choice to Reproductive Justice: De Constitutionalizing Abortion Rights". Yale Law Journal. 118: p.1408
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Consent
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Consent
55 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Consent →
Related Quotes
"Similarly wobbly views on sex and adolescents—or rather sex with adolescents—are on profligate historical display els…"
"Rubenfeld is right that most instances in which one of the parties having sex (or both) have failed to give consent t…"
"In order to answer the question about the conditions under which sex is morally wrong, we need to know what it means …"
"Isabel Grant, a law professor at the University of British Columbia, agreed that the way the Supreme Court rules coul…"
"“Consent is ‘Do you want to have sex this time with this person?’ And we can’t imply that from the fact that you’ve h…"
"The jurisprudence of this Court also establishes that there is no substitute for the complainant’s actual consent to …"
"As stated, informed consent is both a legal obligation and an ethical principle. The requirement that medical provide…"
"These two arguments for inalienability, one looking to coercion and the other to invidious symbolism, begin to merge …"
"“In one sense of the word” observes Robert Lee Hales, “no labor is “involuntary"-not even that of a slave. It is perf…"
"Narrated 'Aisha: I said, "O Allah's Apostle! A virgin feels happy." He said, "Her consent is (expressed by) her silen…"