"In one sense, the Republic is a monologue. No one is presented directly as speaking, other than Socrates himself. But Socrates recounts in great detail a complex conversation that he had with, or in the presence of, ten other persons. I shall come back shortly to the question of the identities of these ten characters. The immediate question is why Socrates is represented as recounting the conversation about the just city to an anonymous audience, that is to say, to no one. Are we meant to infer that the Republic, like Nietzsche’s Thus Spoke Zarathustra, is a book for everyone and no one? Simply to launch a trial balloon, I shall observe that both works are addressed to no one among the contemporaries of the main speaker; Zarathustra is not the superman but the prophet of the coming of the superman, and Socrates, as he makes clear in the Platonic corpus, is unwilling to participate in politics and, given his peculiar nature, he is incapable of doing so. Socrates is thus the "prophet" of the philosopher-king but not one himself."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Stanley Rosen, Plato's Republic: A Study (2005), Introduction
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Thus_Spoke_Zarathustra
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Thus Spoke Zarathustra
72 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Thus Spoke Zarathustra →
Related Quotes
""Leib bin ich und Seele"–so redet das Kind. Und warum sollte man nicht wie die Kinder reden?"
"Und nichts Böses wächst mehr fürderhin aus dir, es sei denn das Böse, das aus dem Kampfe deiner Tugenden wächst. Mein…"
"A light has dawned for me: I need companions, living ones, not dead companions and corpses which I carry with me wher…"
"Keine geringe Kunst ist schlafen: es tut schon Noth, den ganzen Tag darauf hin zu wachen."
"»Je mehr er hinauf in die Höhe und Helle will, um so stärker streben seine Wurzeln erdwärts, abwärts, in's Dunkle, Ti…"
"Es ist mehr Vernunft in deinem Leibe, als in deiner besten Weisheit."
"Im Gebirge ist der nächste Weg von Gipfel zu Gipfel: aber dazu musst du lange Beine haben. Sprüche sollen Gipfel sein…"
""We have invented happiness" -say the last men and blink"
"Welches ist der große Drache, den der Geist nicht mehr Herr und Gott heißen mag? "Du-sollst" heißt der große Drache. …"
"Von allem Geschriebenen liebe ich nur Das, was Einer mit seinem Blute schreibt."