"It is important to note once again that the prohibition of murder and abortion must be appreciated in a therapeutic, not a juridical or punitive light, with which such offenses are often regarded in most Western moral, philosophical, and theological systems: the goal is not to subject the sinner to just punishment, but to bring the sinner through repentance and God’s grace to holiness. Because of this perspective the Orthodox Church never endorsed a doctrine of double effect, such as developed in the West, which allowed Roman Catholicism to approve of indirect abortions. The doctrine of double effects holds that when an action produces two effects, one good and one evil, one may nevertheless act, as long as the act is not evil in itself, the good effect is not produced by the bad effect, the evil effect is not intended,, and there is a proportionate reason (more good will be produced than evil). According to the doctrine of double effect, when these conditions are fulfilled, one is held to be juridically innocent. In contrast, the Orthodox Church recognizes that close causal involvement in the death of another, whether a guilty or an innocent person, may harm one’s spiritual life. Orthodox Christianity recognizes harms from both involuntary and “justifiable” homicide, including homicide in a just war, both of which incur excommunication not as punishment, but as spiritual therapy (Basil, 1983, Canon 13, pp. 801-802). It is in this spiritually therapeutic context that one should understand the absolution of women who miscarry. The absolution expresses the Orthodox Christian healing approach to the involuntary loss of life."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
H. Trisram Engelhardt, Jr., “Orthodox Christian Bioethics: Medical Morality in the Mind of the Fathers”; in Mark Cherry; John F. Peppin (2013). Religious Perspectives in Bioethics. Taylor & Francis. ISBN 9781317762416; "Bioethical Norms: Morality as Spiritual Therapy"; pp.27-28
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Principle_of_double_effect
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Principle of double effect
10 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Principle of double effect →
Related Quotes
"The first application of the principle of double effect, and one of the most consistently important issues in medical…"
"The use of contraceptives can be morally acceptable in other contexts as well, again, because such uses do not consti…"
"The Roman church argues that although the death of the fetus is foreseen, it is not intended because the intention is…"
"At first, no Catholic theologians supported even this qualified endorsement of the pill for contraceptive purposes. U…"
"If there is a single element within Catholic casuistry that characterizes its analyses, it is the doctrine of the dou…"
"It is absolutely true that the Catholic Church bans abortion to save the life of the mother. However (and this is an …"
"The principle of the "double effect" also applies to sexual sterilization. If a woman must have a hysterectomy to rem…"
"The legitimate defense of persons and societies is not an exception to the prohibition against the murder of the inno…"
"Deliberately we have always used the expression 'direct attempt on the life of an innocent person,' 'direct killing.'…"
"I was perversely delighted to see the Catholic Church and the Vatican go after nuns because I think they made a major…"