"The severe difficulties in attempting a rigorous reconstruction of Proto-Tibeto-Burman on this basis [of scant data] have not prevented certain hardy souls from leaping to ever more far-flung comparisons (particularly of Tibetan or Burmese with Old Chinese, or even with Thai) in an attempt to say something about the great Sino-Tibetan proto-language. There are no doubt those who would have tried to reconstruct Proto-Indo-European simply on the testimony of Provençal, Avestan, and Old Norse. We are only now becoming more realistic. It seems wiser to concentrate for the time being on reconstructing PTB sub-group by sub-group..."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
"[Review of] Proto Lolo-Burmese by Robbins Burling" (1968) (p.879)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/James_Matisoff
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
James Matisoff
16 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by James Matisoff →
Related Quotes
"Bilingual humor may be viewed as a relatively benign response to the frustrations inherent in living in such a lingui…"
"In the Beginning was the Sino-Tibetan monosyllable, arrayed in its full consonantal and vocalic splendor. And the syl…"
"The long drought in Tibeto-Burman and Sino-Tibetan historical linguistics is over. The field is opening up now as nev…"
"Rhinoglottophilia–an affinity between the feature of nasality and the articulatory involvement of the glottis–is more…"
"Semantic shifting goes by many different names. In his pioneering article, Benedict 1939 calls it "semantic different…"
"...the more I learn about Lahu the less I think I know. It has seemed that the more fluently I came to speak the lang…"
"I suggest that the reconstruction of PTB [Proto-Tibeto-Burman] is a noble enterprise, where a spirit of competitive t…"
"There can be no more solemn duty for the comparative linguist than to reconstruct his language family's word for the …"
"I remember particularly a moment just before leaving for Japan and Thailand in 1976, when I was gazing forlornly at t…"
"The South-East Asian mono-syllable often seems to be bulging at the seams with phonetic material: consonantal, vocali…"