"Far from being uplifted by their history, the Scots have over many centuries been strikingly bad at maintaining and developing a useful sense of national identity. Worse, Scotland lost much of the self-image it once possessed. Medieval Scotland was a considerable achievement of dynastic politics over poverty and localism. It boasted four universities to England's two, and into the 16th century, Scottish culture was famous across Europe. This mental world of renaissance latinity sustained a Scots identity built around dynastic history and religion rather than the folk culture of Robert Burns. It was this which went disastrously wrong... The Glorious Revolution, ardently espoused by Scots Presbyterians, began the break-up and suppression of this high culture of latinity, episcopalianism and dynastic legitimacy. With dour thoroughness, episcopalians and nonjurors were expelled from their posts as clergy, schoolmasters and academics, and were subjected to lasting and effective persecution. Presbyterians hailed William III, and later the Hanoverians, as saviours of their religious and civil liberties; but, far more than in England, Scots were divided. Presbyterianism survived at the cost of sacrificing a national identity which had grown up in another mental world."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
University of Cambridge alumniUniversity of Cambridge facultyUniversity of Oxford facultyHistorians from the United Kingdom
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
'Scotland's false romanticism', The Times (3 March 1992), p. 12
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/J._C._D._Clark
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
J. C. D. Clark
Jonathan Charles Douglas Clark (born 28 February 1951) is a British historian of both British and American history. He was an undergraduate at Downing College, Cambridge. Having previously held posts at Peterhouse, Cambridge and All Souls College, Oxford into 1996, he has since held the Joyce C. and Elizabeth Ann Hall Distinguished Professorship of British History at the University of Kansas.
28 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by J. C. D. Clark →
Related Quotes
"It has been traditional in British historiography to trace industrial growth and technological innovation to the stur…"
"This perception of a hierarchical order, which was an orthodoxy in England into the early nineteenth century, suddenl…"
"It seemed, then, that to ask the question, "why was there a revolution in the 1640s?" was first to reify the notion, …"
"In any period, as we now see, we have been asked to believe that the rich are always getting richer, the poor always …"
"County studies have succeeded in proving that there was no self-sufficient impetus to rebellion (let alone revolution…"
"The House of Commons under the Georges was far more susceptible to manipulation than it had ever been under Charles I…"
"The rebellions of the 1640s delayed the rise of the English monarchy, but failed to stop it."
"The rebellion of 1688 was not a bid for a weak monarchy, but for a Protestant monarchy. Consequently, the legislative…"
"The model of the atomised, acquisitive individual, dealing with others only through secularised market relations regu…"
"Despite its dubious ancestry, the word "revolution" by now has a Pavlovian effect on some historians: applied to any …"