"(On the question of authenticity there is also a leftist Jewish trend to try and go back to a time before assimilation. For example learning Yiddish and reconnecting to a culture that existed before the holocaust. Is this trend trying to uphold a romantic idealized version of Judaism that cannot exist anymore?) I don’t think learning Yiddish and whatever else they’re doing is pre-assimilation. Jews were speaking Yiddish when they were assimilated. The problem today is that the main Yiddish speakers are Hasidic, but we forget that in New York and Warsaw before the war there were tons of Yiddish speakers who were assimilated. It was more the language of cultural autonomy. The larger debate is something I grapple with too, and it goes back to your question about living off the fumes of a dead culture. But for most cultures, in order to create something new you need to be well steeped in the roots and branches of what came before. So I don’t think it’s simply nostalgia. I think they‘re learning Yiddish as a galvanizing point in order to bound forward with something new, whatever that might be."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Jews from the United StatesCartoonists from the United StatesSocialists from the United StatesCornell University alumni
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Eli_Valley
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Eli Valley
32 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Eli Valley →
Related Quotes
"Ben Shapiro at Seder is a reclamation of Jewish religion, culture, and narrative after years of Shapiro’s hateful inv…"
"Satirizing the powerless is not good satire"
"(What would it mean to have a leftist Jewish community that doesn’t always have to be so reactive — one that’s not al…"
"What’s happening in Israel and what we’ve been ignoring and normalizing for the past ten years has now suddenly hit o…"
"(Is Israel a particularly prescient example for the rise of right-wing politics across the world?) Yes, especially be…"
"They’ve been defining authenticity for so long, but they’re outside the sphere of mainstream political opinion. My fa…"
"It’s outrageous that they claim the mantle of Judaism, while in my view they trespass some of the most basic post-enl…"
"Government is a sterile body and an abstract thing; whereas Jewish issues and Jewish debate gets to the kishkes."
"I am proudly Jewish and it flies in the face of their whole theory of assimilation and that lefty Jews just don’t kno…"
"There aren’t a lot of types of views allowed in the Jewish community and there is a large group of Jewish youth who f…"