"At one time social anthropologists used to complain that their archeologist colleagues had no sense of the overall coherence of human societies. Now, under the influence of Dumézil, who was himself in fluenced by Durkheim and Granet, most of the prehistorians who have specialized in India and Pakistan and most of their Indo- Europeanist philological colleagues have become committed to a functionalism of a wholly naive sort. They seem to assume that cultural systems and language systems are bonded together and intrinsically stable over long periods of time. If societies are left alone, they stay put; otherwise, they roll across the landscape like impermeable billiard balls. If the archeological record shows that in fact changes have occurred, their occurrence is always explained as the consequence of a movement of population that carries with it the products (both material and immaterial) of a preexisting, alien, self-contained culture. As a rule, the alleged movement of people takes the form of a military conquest. The mythology of the Dorian invaders of ancient Greece who reduced their Ionian predecessors to serfdom matches point for point the mythology of the Aryan invasion of northern India."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
University of Cambridge alumniUniversity of Cambridge facultyAnthropologists from EnglandFellows of the British Academy
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Edmund_Leach
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Edmund Leach
22 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Edmund Leach →
Related Quotes
"Time, as we experience it, is continuous; it contains no discrete “events.” The events are put there by reflection on…"
"Records are preserved because they provide a charter for what historians believe about the present. Different histori…"
"In this essay I am mainly concerned with one particular case in which an oral tradition has been treated as if it wer…"
"I am well aware that for an outsider to attempt to bring about a shift in this entrenched paradigm is like trying to …"
"History is only true for the time being; each new generation of scholars rewrites the work of its predecessors. But s…"
"The history of European colonialism covers many centuries and takes diverse forms, but whereas the European explorers…"
"It had the following form: Away back, long before the dawn of true history, Aryan invaders (who spoke a proto-Europea…"
"If we accept all this, then the Aryan invaders appear as a race of chariot-riding heroes who conquer a population of …"
"Common sense might suggest that here was a striking example of a refutable hypothesis that had in fact been refuted. …"
"Why do serious scholars persist in believing in the Aryan invasions?"