"Stuart Newman: Dr. Jaenisch mentioned the scenario of treating diabetics with embryo stem cells. But one of the problems in Type 1 diabetics is that they reject their own insulin producing cells. So even if you could clone that person into a clonal embryo, grow up islet cells and transplant them back into the diabetic, the person's immune system would still reject those cells. So you would have to find some way to immune-suppress the diabetic patients anyway, so as to treat them with embryo stem cells. I think that the American people are very optimistic and only want to hear about the promises, and don't want to hear about the downside. I just point out that in a very recent paper of Dr. Jaenisch 's that he spoke about, where he showed the proof of principle of using stem cells and transplanting differentiated bone marrow cells back into the mouse with the immune deficiency, there was another experiment as well where they corrected the genetic defect in the embryo stem cells. The embryo stem cells were used to produce a full term clone of the original genetically defective mouse, but with the genetic condition corrected. They now had a genetic twin of the original mouse with the corrected gene, and were then able to use bone marrow from that corrected mouse to treat the original mice. Now here's a scenario for which many people would say, “great!” People are already having new children to provide bone marrow for children with genetic conditions. If the public was aware that now you could clone your sick child and use the bone marrow from the new child--whom you'll love like your old child, of course--and transfer that bone marrow back into your sick child, huge sectors of the public would find that acceptable. And this is what I mean when I say that we're on a track where we're coming closer and closer to full term cloning, by way of all sorts of intermediate stages. And it's not that there aren't people already advocating this."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
pp.6-7
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Cloning
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Cloning
74 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Cloning →
Related Quotes
"A prominent biologist Lee Silver, once said that biology would be forever defined as BD and AD: before Dolly and afte…"
"Wilmut has always been clear about his ethical beliefs and has publicly voiced his approval of 'therapeutic cloning',…"
"Hard lessons have been learnt by past situations involving science and secrecy. Nobel Peace Prize winner Joseph Rotbl…"
"First, a suitable surrogate mother animal is required. For the mammoth this would need to be a cow (as best biologica…"
"If there are intact cells in this tissue they have been 'stored' frozen. However, if we think back to what actually h…"
""Let's say that one in a thousand cells were nevertheless viable, practical issues come into play. Given that we have…"
"Considered contrary to the moral law, since (it is in) opposition to the dignity both of human procreation and of the…"
"The delivered kid was genetically identical to the bucardo. In species such as bucardo, cloning is the only possibili…"
"Dr. Josef Mengele: Do you know what I saw on the television in my motel room at one o'clock this morning? Films of Hi…"
"The first obstacle to cloning your dog is that $100,000 cost. The second is getting the right kind of cells. It's eas…"