"A keystone in the traditional short chronology for Indo‐European, for instance, is the perception that Avestan and Vedic are ‘so close’ that the divergence between them ‘must’ be but a matter of a few centuries. Sims‐Williams (1998: 126), for example, offers selected sentences that “may be transposed from the one language into the other merely by observing the appropriate phonological rules.” Much the same, though, can be said of selected phrases in Italian and Spanish, for instance: see Heggarty and Renfrew (2014: 545). Change and divergence have been minimal in no end of word pairs, such as Italian [liŋgwa] vs. Spanish [lɛŋgwa] tongue (from Latin [liŋgʷa]), [mɔndo]~[mundo] world, [θjelo]~[t͡ʃelo] sky, etc. Indeed, other cases show no real divergence at all: [kanto]~[kanto] I sing, [salta]~[salta] s/he jumps, and so on. Here too, simply applying phonological rules can straightforwardly transpose one language to the other, but that hardly proves a time‐depth of divergence of just a few centuries, as traditionally envisaged between Avestan and Vedic. For the net diver- gence between Italian and Spanish to arise, out of Latin, took the same two millennia that in French saw much more radical change."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Bayesian Phylolinguistics . SIMON J. GREENHILL,1 PAUL HEGGARTY,2 AND RUSSELL D. GRAY in , The Handbook of Historical Linguistics, Volume II
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Avestan
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Avestan
2 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Avestan →
Related Quotes
"I was not a little surprised to find that out of ten words in Du Perron’s Zind Dictionary, six or seven were pure San…"
"I was not a little surprised to find that out of ten words in Du Perron’s Zind Dictionary, six or seven were pure San…"
"It remains quite clear, however, that Indic and Iranian developed from different Indo-European dialects, whose period…"
"The Iranian family, which was next to sweep across the steppe and deserts, finds its region of greatest diversity in …"
"Prior to the Turkic expansion, at the beginning of the Iron Age, Iranian spread from somewhere in the vicinity of Bac…"
"It is still a hazardous task to connect the archaeological evidence… in the Central Asian steppe with the appearance …"
"Zarathustra's god is a unique god. This is a concept that is not only foreign to the entire Iranian tradition, but is…"
"He has all the attributes of a very high God, because he is omniscient, very wise, guardian and defender of his creat…"
"The name Ahura, like the name of Yahveh that the Bible gives to the God of Israel, means the Being, that is, the Bein…"
"All this I have done according to the will of Auramazda: may Auramazda protect me, together with the gods, and (prote…"