"This situation [alienation] can therefore [according to Durkheim] be remedied by providing the individual with a moral awareness of the social importance of his particular role in the division of labour. He is then no longer an alienated automaton. but is a useful part of an organic whole: ‘from that time, as special and uniform as his activity may be, it is that of an intelligent being, for it has direction, and he is aware of it.’ This is entirely consistent with Durkheim’s general account of the growth of the division of labour, and its relationship to human freedom. It is only through moral acceptance in his particular role in the division of labour that the individual is able to achieve a high degree of autonomy as a self-conscious being, and can escape both the tyranny of rigid moral conformity demanded in undifferentiated societies on the one hand and the tyranny of unrealisable desires on the other. Not the moral integration of the individual within a differentiated division of labour but the effective dissolution of the division of labour as an organising principle of human social intercourse, is the premise of Marx’s conception. Marx nowhere specifies in detail how this future society would be organised socially, but, at any rate,. this perspective differs decisively from that of Durkheim. The vision of a highly differentiated division of labour integrated upon the basis of moral norms of individual obligation and corporate solidarity. is quite at variance with Marx’s anticipation of the future form of society. According to Durkheim’s standpoint. the criteria underlying Marx’s hopes for the elimination of technological alienation represent a reversion to moral principles which are no longer appropriate to the modern form of society. This is exactly the problem which Durkheim poses at the opening of The Division of Labour: ‘Is it our duty to seek to become a thorough and complete human being. one quite sufficient unto himself; or, on the contrary, to be only a part of a whole, the organ of an organism?’ The analysis contained in the work, in Durkheim’s view, demonstrates conclusively that organic solidarity is the ‘normal’ type in modern societies, and consequently that the era of the ‘universal man’ is finished. The latter ideal, which predominated up to the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries in western Europe is incompatible with the diversity of the contemporary order. In preserving this ideal. by contrast. Marx argues the obverse: that the tendencies which are leading to the destruction of capitalism are themselves capable of effecting a recovery of the ‘universal’ properties of man. which are shared by every individual."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
pp. 230-231.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Anthony_Giddens
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Anthony Giddens
13 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Anthony Giddens →
Related Quotes
"Political economy … founds its theory of society upon the self-seeking of the isolated individual. Political economy,…"
"The main dimensions of Marx’s discussion of alienation are as follows: ... 1. The worker … has no power to determine …"
"It is usually assumed that, in speaking, in the 1844 Manuscripts, of man’s “being reduced to the level of the animals…"
"The main form of crude communism is based upon emotional antipathy towards private property, and asserts that all men…"
"Human consciousness is conditioned in a dialectical interplay between subject and object, in which man actively shape…"
"The expropriated peasantry are “turned en masse into beggars, vagabonds, partly from inclination, in most cases from …"
"The concept of the “isolated individual” is a construction of the bourgeois philosophy of individualism, and serves t…"
"Marx rejects as “absurd” the contention made by John Stuart Mill, and many of the political economists, that while pr…"
"The main defect of idealism in philosophy and history is that it attempts to analyze the properties of societies by i…"
"To renew the energy expended in physical labour, the worker must be provided with the requirements of his existence a…"