"However, Seidenberg was told by the Indologists that these Sutras, or any Vedic text for that matter, were definitely written later than 1700 BC. But mathematical data cannot be manipulated just like that, and Seidenberg remained convinced of his case: “Whatever the difficulty there may be [concerning chronology], it is small in comparison with the difficulty of deriving the Vedic ritual application of the theorem from Babylonia. (The reverse derivation is easy)… the application involves geometric algebra, and there is no evidence of geometric algebra from Babylonia. And the geometry of Babylonia is already secondary whereas in India it is primary.” [To satisfy the indologists, he said that the Shulba Sutra had conserved an older tradition, and that it is from this one that the Babylonians had learned their mathematics:] “Hence we do not hesitate to place the Vedic (…) rituals, or more exactly, rituals exactly like them, far back of 1700 BC. (…) elements of geometry found in Egypt and Babylonia stem from a ritual system of the kind described in the Sulvasutras.”"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Academics from the United StatesPeople from Washington, D.C.Historians from the United StatesMathematicians from the United StatesUniversity of California, Berkeley faculty
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Abraham Seidenberg
Abraham Seidenberg (June 2, 1916 – May 3, 1988) was an American mathematician.
15 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Abraham Seidenberg →
Related Quotes
"Seidenberg (1983), a historian of science, described the reaction to Thibaut's claim: "Thibaut himself never belabore…"
"By examining the evidence in the Shatapatha Brahmana, we now know that Indian geometry predates Greek geometry by cen…"
"Its mathematics was very much like what we see in the Sulvasutras [szulbasu utras]. In the first place, it was associ…"
"‘Greece and India have a common heritage that cannot have derived from Old-Babylonia, i.e., the Old-Babylonia of abou…"
"‘A comparison of Pythagorean and Vedic mathematics together with some chronological consideration showed that the cur…"
"I think its mathematics [of the common source] was very much like what we see in the Sulbasutras. (Seidenberg 1978)"
"I cannot help thinking that it shows battle weariness rather than a considered opinion."
"Yet long before 1937 people had suggested a non-Greek origin to Greek mathematics; and long before 1943 people had po…"
"[…] nor did he [Thibaut] formulate the obvious conclusion, namely, that the Greeks were not the inventors of plane ge…"
"If the Indians invented plane geometry, what was to become of Greek ‘genius’ or of the Greek ‘miracle’?"