"The project's advocates imagine that the problem, if they recognise one at all, lies in the variable quality of Wikipedia's individual entries. The solution is obvious: a process in which editors work on the less successful entries and remove the obviously unmerited ones. In reality, the problem is much more fundamental to Wikipedia than that much of its content is a pile of dross. Whereas science and learning pursue truth, Wikipedia prizes consensus. Wikipedia has no means of arbitrating between different claims, other than how many people side with one position rather than another. That ethos is fatal to the advancement of learning. Ideas are refined by being tested; scientific method presupposes scrutiny, experiment and conflict."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
The original title of the article was "Wikipedia is junk", but in the archived save it has become deformed to simply "Wikipedia".
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Wikipedia
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Wikipedia
221 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Wikipedia →
Related Quotes
"After a year or so of working on Nupedia, Larry had the idea to use Wiki software for a separate project specifically…"
"What if we could get everyone in the world together to record what they know in one place?"
"At present I am overworked and the [Nupedia] project is suffering to some extent as a result... I just don't have the…"
"I take a half-full-glass view, based on a different understanding of what [Wikipedia's competition is]: not the tradi…"
"It's an idea to add a little feature to Nupedia. ..."Wiki," pronounced \wee'-kee\, derives from a Polynesian word, "w…"
"We wouldn't call it "the Nupedia wiki" though that's what it would be. ... On the "wikipedia" we would say that this …"
"It was a cold Friday evening in January 2001. I was on duty in one of my uni's computer labs..."
"Hello, World!"
"...why 2 sites, or 2 encyclopedias? My impression of them is Wikipedia is the "everyman's" encyclopedia and Nupedia i…"
"Wikis don't work if people aren't bold. You've got to get out there and make those changes, correct that grammar, add…"