"In an interview, Adam Hochschild, the prominent historian and award-winning author of books including “American Midnight: The Great War, A Violent Peace, and Democracy’s Forgotten Crisis,” was clear-eyed about what America is facing: “This is profoundly frightening because it’s right out of the playbook of the way democracies are converted to dictatorships.” He compared our present moment to what was happening a century ago in the aftermath of World War I and the Russian Revolution. The country, he said in an email interview, was “inflamed by military fervor…and then by paranoia,” which caused “severe damage to democracy.” “The government shut down some 75 newspapers and magazines, and imprisoned hundreds of people — most notably Socialist leader Eugene V. Debs — solely for things they wrote or said,” Hochschild said. “Donald Trump would greatly like to do the same, as his attacks on critical media and prosecutions of people like James Comey show. But he is going one step further than this country went during the madness of the Red Scare of 1917-1921 by trying to seize control of electoral machinery. That, to me, is the most frightening thing about an already dangerous presidency.” Commentators get hung up, he explained, on comparing Trump to Republican Sen. Joseph McCarthy of Wisconsin, who saw “subversives everywhere.” While noting similarities, Hochschild argued the better parallel is Democratic President Woodrow Wilson who, in his second term, “did all kinds of things Trump would like to do, such as throwing his critics in jail under the Espionage Act by the hundreds, and shutting down media that criticized him.” But that wasn’t all. Under the 28th president, the Justice Department created the American Protective League, which Hochschild described as “a national vigilante force [that] scoured cities for suspected draft-dodgers.” “We pay far too little attention to that ominous period of American life,” he said, “always preferring to look on the bright side rather than the dark side.”"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Chauncey DeVega, new Red Scare? This could be much worse", Salon, 5 October 2025
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Trumpism
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Trumpism
28 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Trumpism →
Related Quotes
"Donald Trump destroyed the Reagan Republican paradigm in 2016, but he didn’t exactly elucidate a new set of ideas, po…"
"NatCons are also probably right that conservatism is going to get a lot more statist. At the conference, Ted Cruz tri…"
"The booing began. I’d been dreading it for days, but when it came, I almost welcomed it. There is nothing more freein…"
"Since Trump was first elected in 2016, America’s responsible political and media class have constructed a model of Am…"
"Trumpism is the embodiment of Shakespeare’s observation that what’s past is prologue. It’s now our present and future…"
"The triumph of a raw populism, embodied by a shameless demagogue, over both the official establishment and the offici…"
"Trumpism is also a celebrity-driven , forged by its leader’s unique reality-television appeal. This has made it relat…"
"Trumpism is here to stay."
"[W]hile Trump is not going to be president, Trumpism is going to survive. ...[T]he Democrats need to look very very c…"
"Trumpism, broadly defined as secure borders, , and America-first foreign policy."