"It is difficult, however, to avoid the feeling that in this mild latter-day anarchism of Kropotkin something has been lost of that fierce dynamic of revolt which animated the anarchism of Bakunin. Bakunin's indignation at the wickedness of the tyrant was no doubt accompanied by a naive faith in the constructive capacity and untutored goodness of the masses. In Kropotkin this faith has got mixed up with the Victorian belief in the inevitability of progress. His anarchism, no less than Marx's communism, claimed to have a scientific foundation. It was "more than a mere mode of action or a mere conception of a free society"; it was "part of a philosophy, natural and social", and "must be treated by the same methods as natural sciences". In pursuit of this conception Kropotkin wrote what was once probably the most famous of all his works, Mutual Aid, in which he demonstrated, in contradiction to the Darwinian theory of progress through the struggle for existence, that animal life, as well as primitive human societies, survived not through processes of mutual destruction but through processes of cooperation. Towards this conception human society was constantly and continuously evolving. To-day such conceptions seem as faded and irrelevant as the pseudo-scientific political applications of Darwinism which they were intended to refute. And with them goes the pseudo-scientific optimism about the progressive evolution of human nature which was the basis of Kropotkin's anarchist creed."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
E. H. Carr, "Kropotkin" (1951), published in From Napoleon to Stalin and Other Essays (1980)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Peter_Kropotkin
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Peter Kropotkin
161 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Peter Kropotkin β
Related Quotes
"That we are Utopians is well known. So Utopian are we that we go the length of believing that the Revolution can and β¦"
"Oh, the beautiful utopia, the lovely Christmas dream we can make as soon as we admit that those who govern represent β¦"
"Have not prisons β which kill all will and force of character in man, which enclose within their walls more vices thaβ¦"
"Once a German jurist of great renown, Ihering, wanted to sum up the scientific work of his life and write a treatise,β¦"
"It is often said that Anarchists live in a world of dreams to come, and do not see the things which happen today. We β¦"
"Ah, if men were those superior beings that the utopians of authority like to speak to us of, if we could close our eyβ¦"
"What we do want is so to arrange things that every human being born into the world shall be ensured the opportunity iβ¦"
"Has not experience demonstrated quite recently that Jack the Ripper performed his exploits under the eye of the Londoβ¦"
"When we ask for the abolition of the State and its organs we are always told that we dream of a society composed of mβ¦"
"When we ask ourselves by what means a certain moral level can be maintained in a human or animal society, we find onlβ¦"