"Yet we are not always justified in concluding that the killing of animals causes a less number to exist; because some of them are carnivorous, and by being killed they can no longer kill others: while others are graminivorous, and when they can no longer eat up the fruits of the soil, other animals may live upon such fruits instead; still there is no justification of slaughter, as the identical lives are certainly thereby destroyed; and if such an excuse be admitted, it must apply by the same rule to the slaughter even of human beings. But however this may be, it is evident that by far the greatest number of animals live in terror and die by violence from their devourers, and the males also by the attacks of each other, besides pestilence, diseases, accidents and starvation, few living their natural time; while by means of many being sacrificed, a few are enabled to live like in a ship of short provision, though without an equitable casting of lots, but by the law of force over weakness; and this law not being confined to dumb animals, but ruling the lots of man as well as of animals, though its operations on human life may be more concealed, but here also population is kept in check by want of food and by warfare; among mankind itself justice is little more than a name, might being the chief law observed: here, too, the strong destroy and oppress the weak; some are enabled to live and multiply, while many starve and live in celibacy to prevent an overflow, which, notwithstanding, does arise: dispute and warfare then result in which some are destroyed and some preserved. But no person, however virtuous, can live in comfort without consuming more than his share. Such is the world we live in, however Pope may contend that "virtue alone is happiness below.""
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Jews from the United KingdomInventorsActivists from EnglandNon-fiction authors from EnglandAnimal rights activists
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
The System of Nature and Duty of Man to Animals, p. 14
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Lewis_Gompertz
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Lewis Gompertz
(1783/4 – 2 December 1861) was an English philosopher, writer, inventor, and social reformer. He was best known for his pioneering advocacy of the moral consideration of animals, early veganism, and opposition to animal exploitation. A founding member of the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (later the RSPCA), he later established the Animals' Friend Society to promote a more comprehensive ethical stance toward animals. His 1824 treatise, Moral Inquiries on the Situation of Man an
48 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Lewis Gompertz →
Related Quotes
"Y: What are your opinions concerning the propriety of using silk? Z: I disapprove of the act of depriving the living …"
"The force of custom or habits even proverbial; and accordingly we take advantage of the magnified representation in w…"
"Are [animals] not furnished with most feelings similar to our own? They indisputably evince in an eminent degree most…"
"It has been generally, but not always, the custom of naturalists to degrade the powers of dumb animals into mere inst…"
"In order to admire the goodness of God with the greatest force, we should endeavour to reach in imagination the impro…"
"[T]his seems to be still the age of infancy, and baby-like do we cry. This is all made for me! The land and the ocean…"
"[E]very animal has more right to the use of its own body than others have to use it."
"Suppose...we reflect on the building of London Bridge, we cannot then help admiring the genius and assiduity of man. …"
"[H]owever the state of man may be above that of other animals, if the superiority be owing to his being differently s…"
"And though I cannot conceive how any person can shut his eyes to the general state of misery throughout the universe,…"