"The failure of utilitarianism to address a will in which it does not altogether believe stands in sharp contrast to the mainstream of liberal thought represented by the great German philosopher, Immanuel Kant. For Kant, liberalism was first and last about the will....Like Christianity, Kantian liberalism identifies the greatest need of humans, as self-conscious beings, as the need for a rule of conduct, the means of governing oneself as a free and responsible agent.Modern economism's failure is that it does not face up to this question of self-government or address the issue of what is required to make the empire of the will legitimate. For the utilitarian maxim that pleasure or happiness should be maximized fails to acknowledge the need to govern the empire of the will. It provides instead an aggregative criterion for public decision-making, a criterion which is defective because it does not provide for the claims of justice. But that failure over justice reflects, in turn, utilitarianism's failure to distinguish between persons as separate and autonomous agents, as rational agents who need a rule by which to regulate their own wills. Utilitarianism merely aggregates satisfactions, looking upon society as a kind of collective self."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
University of Oxford facultyHarvard University alumniUniversity of Oxford alumniPeople from ChicagoImmigrants to the United Kingdom
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
10. Europe, Christianity and Islam (pp. 191–192)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Larry_Siedentop
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Larry Siedentop
Sir Larry Alan Siedentop CBE (24 May 1936 – 13 June 2024) was an American-born British political philosopher with a special interest in 19th-century French liberalism. He was the author of Democracy in Europe (2000) and Inventing the Individual (2014) and an occasional contributor to several major British daily newspapers, including the Financial Times and The Times.
11 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Larry Siedentop →
Related Quotes
"Liberalism, the dominant ideology of our time, has been dangerously distorted by the impact of economism. It is that …"
"The institutions of the European Union are at present incomplete. A European Senate is badly needed to complete them.…"
"If we want to understand the distinctive constitution of Europe, we must go back to its religious foundations. For th…"
"We have become victims of our own success. For we are in danger of taking this primacy of the individual as something…"
"The Jewish sense of time was...unilinear rather than cyclical. Even the repeated lapses of Israel into idolatry did n…"
"Only the pride of the intellect could suppose that the human will can be completely self-determining. The incarnation…"
"In the twelfth century, reason began to lose the ontologically privileged position it had been accorded by an aristoc…"
"Paul and Augustine transformed Jewish belief in a divine will directed at a ‘chosen’ people. They universalized the c…"
"Christianity changed the ground of human identity. It was able to do that because of the way it combined Jewish monot…"
"What is the crux of secularism? It is that belief in an underlying or moral equality of humans implies that there is …"