"However, even those who expect deterrence to work might hesitate at introducing a new weapon system that increased the reliability of deterrence, but at the cost of increasing the possible casualties by a factor of 10, that is, there would then be one or two billion hostages at risk if their expectations fail. Neither the 180 million Americans nor even the half billion people in the NATO alliance should or would be willing to design and procure a security system in which a malfunction or failure would cause the death of one or two billion people. If the choice were made explicit, the United States or NATO would seriously consider "lower quality" systems; i.e.,systems which were less deterring, but whose consequences were less catastrophic if deterrence failed. They would even consider such possibilities as a dangerous degree of partial or complete unilateral disarmament, if there were no other acceptable postures. The West might be willing to procure a military system which, if used in a totally irrational and unrealistic way, could cause such damage, but only if all of the normal or practically conceivable abnormal ways of operating the system would not do anything like the hypothesized damage. On the other hand, we would not let the Soviets cynically blackmail us into accommodation by a threat on their part to build a Doomsday Machine, even though we would not consciously build a strategic system which inevitably forced the Soviets to build a Doomsday Machine in self-defense."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Atheists from the United StatesJews from the United StatesPeople from New JerseyPhysicists from the United StatesGame theorists
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Herman_Kahn
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Herman Kahn
Herman Kahn (February 15, 1922 – July 7, 1983) was an American futurist and nuclear theorist. He was one of the founders of the Hudson Institute and an employee of the RAND corporation. He is most known for his work On Thermonuclear War.
30 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Herman Kahn →
Related Quotes
"The Russians aren't dedicated world dominationists. You know, they just sort of want it on account of a sentimental w…"
"He flips to a drawing of a spindly boy wearing oversized glasses, hugging an ABC primer, and sniffing a daisy. This i…"
"The next picture is a Goliath with four arms, reading a book, lofting a 1000-pound dumbbell, aiming a pistol at a tar…"
"He ambles along the platform."Lots of times people say about systems analysis, why don't you guys do an experiment? W…"
"Actually, even with tested missiles, results of attacks are not really mathematically predictable. The probability of…"
"Even if military advantages were not to be had by deliberately limiting attack to counterforce targets, I suspect tha…"
"The difference between megaton and kiloton is very large, in some ways larger than the difference between kiloton and…"
"The final outcome of benevolent, informed, and intelligent decisions may turn out to be disastrous. But choices must …"
"In addition to the obvious dangers, there is another subtle but by no means minor disadvantage to a pure deterrence p…"
"The usual image of war today held by many experts as well as most laymen can be summed up in the phrase "orgiastic sp…"