"If we except the great name of Newton (and the exception is one that the great Gauss himself would have been delighted to make) it is probable that no mathematician of any age or country has ever surpassed Gauss in the combination of an abundant fertility of invention with an absolute vigorousness in demonstration, which the ancient Greeks themselves might have envied. It may be admitted, without any disparagement to the eminence of such great mathematicians as Euler and Cauchy that they were so overwhelmed with the exuberant wealth of their own creations, and so fascinated by the interest attaching to the results at which they arrived, that they did not greatly care to expend their time in arranging their ideas in a strictly logical order, or even in establishing by irrefragable proof propositions which they instinctively felt, and could almost see to be true. With Gauss the case was otherwise. It may seem paradoxical, but it is probably nevertheless true that it is precisely the effort after a logical perfection of form which has rendered the writings of Gauss open to the charge of obscurity and unnecessary difficulty. The fact is that there is neither obscurity nor difficulty in his writings, as long as we read them in the submissive spirit in which an intelligent schoolboy is made to read his Euclid. Every assertion that is made is fully proved, and the assertions succeed one another in a perfectly just analogical order... But when we have finished the perusal, we soon begin to feel that our work is but begun, that we are still standing on the threshold of the temple, and that there is a secret which lies behind the veil and is as yet concealed from us. No vestige appears of the process by which the result itself was obtained, perhaps not even a trace of the considerations which suggested the successive steps of the demonstration. Gauss says more than once that for brevity, he gives only the synthesis, and suppresses the analysis of his propositions. Pauca sed matura—few but well matured... If, on the other hand, we turn to a memoir of Euler's, there is a sort of free and luxuriant gracefulness about the whole performance, which tells of the quiet pleasure which Euler must have taken in each step of his work; but we are conscious nevertheless that we are at an immense distance from the severe grandeur of design which is characteristic of all Gauss's greater efforts."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
People from DublinUniversity of Oxford facultyUniversity of Oxford alumniMathematicians from Ireland
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
As quoted by , Lectures on Ten British Physicists of the Nineteenth Century (1916) p. 95, "Henry John Stephen Smith (1826-1883) A Lecture delivered March 15, 1902"
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Henry_John_Stephen_Smith
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Henry John Stephen Smith
Henry John Stephen Smith (2 November 1826 – 9 February 1883) was a mathematician remembered for his work in elementary divisors, quadratic forms, matrix theory, and number theory.
17 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Henry John Stephen Smith →
Related Quotes
"So intimate is the union between Mathematics and Physics that probably by far the larger part of the accessions to ou…"
"We must confine ourselves to what we may term the great highways of the science; and... we must wholly pass by many o…"
"The problem of the direct determination of the primitive roots of a prime number is one of the 'cruces' of the Theory…"
"'Legendre's Law of Quadratic Reciprocity' ... is ...the most important general truth in the science of integral numbe…"
"The first demonstration (Disq. Arith., Arts. 125-145) which is presented by Gauss in a form very repulsive to any but…"
"I do not know what Henry Smith may be at the subjects of which he professes to know something; but I never go to him …"
"Though not a poet or creative genius, he was... possessed of greater natural abilities than any one else whom I have …"
"In those days he was almost equally a lover of Classics and Mathematics. ...Even in the last years of his life he was…"
"His mathematical speculations could have been shared by a very few, not more than two or three, of his contemporaries…"
"He was very desirous to promote the interests of Natural Science in Oxford, and was in favour of some measure which w…"