"Go into a garden of plants, grass, flowers. No matter how lovely it seems. Even in the mildest season of the year. You will not be able to look anywhere and not find suffering. That whole family of vegetation is in a state of 'souffrance', each in its own way to some degree. Here a rose is attacked by the sun, which has given it life; it withers, languishes, wilts. There a lily is sucked cruelly by a bee, in its most sensitive, most life-giving parts. Sweet honey is not produced by industrious, patient, good, virtuous bees without unspeakable torment for those most delicate fibers, without the pitiless massacre of flowerets. That tree is infested by an ant colony, that other one by caterpillars, flies, snails, mosquitoes; this one is injured in its bark and afflicted by the air or by the sun penetrating the wound; that other one has a damaged trunk, or roots; that other has many dry leaves; that other one has its flowers gnawed at, nibbled; that other one has its fruits pierced, eaten away. That plant is too warm, this one too cold; too much light, too much shade; too wet, too dry. One cannot grow or spread easily because there are obstacles and obstructions; another finds nowhere to lean, or has trouble and struggles to reach any support. In the whole garden you will not find a single plant in a state of perfect health. Here a branch is broken by the wind or by its own weight; there a gentle breeze is tearing a flower apart, and carries away a piece, a filament, a leaf, a living part of this or that plant, which has broken or been torn off. Meanwhile you torture the grass by stepping on it; you grind it down, crush it, squeeze out its blood, break it, kill it. A sensitive and gentle young maiden goes sweetly cutting and breaking off stems. A gardener expertly chops down trunks, breaking off sensitive limbs, with his nails, with his tools. Certainly these plants live on; some because their infirmities are not fatal, others because even with fatal diseases, plants, and animals as well, can manage to live on a little while. The spectacle of such abundance of life when you first go into this garden lifts your spirits, and that is why you think it is a joyful place. But in truth this life is wretched and unhappy, every garden is like a vast hospital (a place much more deplorable than a cemetery), and if these beings feel, or rather, were to feel, surely not being would be better for them than being."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Giacomo Leopardi, trans. Kathleen Baldwin et al., Zibaldone (2013), [4175-4177]
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Wild_animal_suffering
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Related Quotes
"I also naturally come to the conclusion that you are the avowed enemy of men, and all other creatures of your creatio…"
"[S]uch order cannot exist without evil ... Animals destined for the nourishment of other species. The inborn envy and…"
"ICELANDER: Thus I reply to you. I am well aware you did not make the world for the service of men. It were easier to …"
"Whilst they discussed these and similar questions, two lions are said to have suddenly appeared. The beasts were so e…"
"Death is not an evil, because it frees us from all evils, and while it takes away good things, it takes away also the…"
"NATURE: So flees the squirrel from the rattlesnake, and runs in its haste deliberately into the mouth of its tormento…"
"Boredom is in some ways the most sublime of human feelings. It is not that I think an examination of this feeling giv…"
"ICELANDER: So say all the philosophers. But since that which is destroyed suffers, and that which is born from its de…"
"In every land the universal vices and ills of mankind and of human society are noted as peculiar to that place. I hav…"
"It seems as though death were the essential aim of all things. That which has no existence cannot die; yet all that e…"